Agents of alienation: accountants and the land grab of Papua New Guinea

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to explore and examine the role of accounting and accountants in customary land transactions between Indigenous peoples and foreign corporate entities. The paper uses the case of two accountants who utilised accounting technologies in lease agreements to alienate customary land from Indigenous landowners in Papua New Guinea (PNG). Design/methodology/approach Employing a case study methodology, the paper draws on contemporary data sets of transcripts related to a Commission of Inquiry established in 2011 to investigate PNG’s Special Agricultural Business Lease system. Analysis of other publicly available data and semi-structured interviews with PNG landowners and other stakeholders supplement and triangulate data from the inquiry transcripts. A Bourdieusian lens was adopted to conceptualise how accounting was used in the struggles for customary land between foreign developers and Indigenous landowners within the wider capitalist field and the traditional Melanesian field. Findings This paper reveals how accountants exploited PNG’s customary land registration system, the Indigenous peoples’ lack of financial literacy and their desperation for development to alienate customary land from landowners. The accountants employed accounting technologies in the sublease agreements to reduce their royalty obligations to the landowners and to impose penalty clauses that made it financially impossible for the landowners to cancel the leases. The accountants used accounting to normalise, legitimise and rationalise these exploitative arrangements in formal lease contracts. Originality/value This paper responds to the call for research on accounting and Indigenous peoples that is contemporary rather than historic; examines the role of accountants in Indigenous relations, and examines the emancipatory potential of accounting.

Accounting and First Nations: A Systematic Literature Review and Directions for Future Research

“…2015), to demonstrate First Nations peoples as agents rather than victims (Finau et al. 2019). This study's review of recent literature focused on First Nations peoples’ accounting experiences suggests this is an under‐researched field, with only nine research papers capturing the direct experiences of First Nations peoples or reporting entities with accounting and financial reporting published since 2000 (McNicholas et al.…”

Uneven development and its effects: Livelihoods and urban and rural spaces in Papua New Guinea

“…However, royalties to landowners still act as an incentive, even if they flow to very few beneficiaries and cause considerable local conflict (Australian Conservation Foundation, 2006;Lattas, 2011). The forestry industry in PNG has been characterised by endemic corruption and, in recent years, has attempted to use Special Agricultural Business Leases as a means of alienating customary land (Filer, 2011;Filer and Numapo, 2017;Finau et al, 2019). Though PNG politicians have announced that these leases have been cancelled, in reality, the legal status of many Special Agricultural Business Lease agreements remain uncertain (Filer, 2019).…”

Special Issue Editorial: Social and Environmental Account/Ability 2020 and Beyond

“…Examples of issues based research have included work that is motivated by particular concerns e.g. animal welfare (Laine and Vinnari 2017), human rights (McPhail and Ferguson 2016), Indigenous dispossession (Finau, Jacobs, and Chand 2019), and housing (Smyth, Cole, and Fields 2020). And while these issues have been introduced, there is always more to do within particular issues, as well as new issues that emerge.…”