Aging-dependent Functional Alterations of Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) from Human Fibroblasts Transferred into mtDNA-less Cells

Abstract

To investigate the role that aging-dependent accumulation of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations plays in the senescence processes, mitochondria from fibroblasts of 21 normal human individuals between 20 weeks (fetal) and 103 years of age were introduced into human mtDNA-less ( o ) 206 cells by cytoplast ؋ o cell fusion, and 7-31 transformant clones were isolated from each fusion. A slight cell donor age-dependent decrease in growth rate was detected in the transformants. Using an O 2 consumption rate of 1 fmol/min/cell, which was not observed in any transformant among 158 derived from individuals 20 weeks (fetal) to 37 years of age, as a cutoff to identify respiratory-deficient clones, 11 such clones were found among 198 transformants derived from individuals 39 -103 years of age. Furthermore, conventional and nonparametric analysis of the respiratory rates of 356 clones revealed a very significant decrease with donor age. In other analyses, a very significant age-dependent decline in the mtDNA content of the clones was observed, without, however, any significant correlation with the decrease in O 2 consumption rate in the defective transformants. These observations clearly indicate the occurrence in the fibroblast-derived transformants of two independent, age-related functional alterations of mtDNA, presumably resulting from structural damage to this genome.Since the free radical theory of aging was first proposed (1), a voluminous amount of data has accumulated indicating that free radicals contribute to the degeneration of biological systems (2-4). Over 90% of the oxygen consumed by mammalian cells is utilized in mitochondria, and up to 4% of this oxygen is transformed into excited oxygen species (5). It is assumed that oxygen-free radicals are produced in mitochondria at a rate proportional to cellular metabolism, and that reaction with these free radicals may cause progressive damage to mitochondrial macromolecules during the life of the organism, contributing to the phenotypic effects of aging (3, 6 -8). In particular, it has been hypothesized by Linnane and collaborators (6) that accumulation of mtDNA 1 mutations is a major contributor to aging and degenerative diseases, due to the high mutation rate of mtDNA, which is 10 times higher than that of single-copy nuclear genes (9), to the size and compactness of the mitochondrial genome, to the lack of histones, to the lack or inefficiency of repair mechanisms, and to the somatic segregation of mitochondrial genomes during cell division (6). Substantial support for this suggestion has come from biochemical, histochemical, and immunohistochemical evidence of a progressive deterioration with aging of the respiratory capacity of different tissues, which exhibits a characteristic intercellular mosaicism of mitochondrial dysfunction (10 -16), as well as from the demonstration of aging-related mtDNA damage in the form of large deletions (17-23), small deletions and insertions (24), and oxidative adducts of DNA (25-28). However, it has been impossible thus far to d...

Nuclear-recessive Mutations of Factors Involved in Mitochondrial Translation Are Responsible for Age-related Respiration Deficiency of Human Skin Fibroblasts

“…1). Therefore, the apparent discrepancy between the report of Laderman et al (12) and ours (11) could be due simply to a difference in the interpretation of observations.…”

“…Recently, using an mtDNA transfer system similar to ours (11), i.e. mtDNA transfer from human skin fibroblasts to 0 human cells, Laderman et al (12) reported contradictory results, suggesting the presence of age-related heritable alterations in fibroblast mtDNA. However, the procedure for isolating cybrids by the transfer of fibroblast mtDNA to 0 cells is not appropriate for unambiguous determination of whether accumulation of mtDNA mutations is involved in age-related mitochondrial dysfunction, because during selection to exclude 0 cells using medium without uridine and/or pyruvate, cybrids expressing respiration deficiency due to accumulation of mtDNA mutations might also be eliminated preferentially, so that only cybrids with normal mitochondrial respiratory function are isolated.…”

“…However, the procedure for isolating cybrids by the transfer of fibroblast mtDNA to 0 cells is not appropriate for unambiguous determination of whether accumulation of mtDNA mutations is involved in age-related mitochondrial dysfunction, because during selection to exclude 0 cells using medium without uridine and/or pyruvate, cybrids expressing respiration deficiency due to accumulation of mtDNA mutations might also be eliminated preferentially, so that only cybrids with normal mitochondrial respiratory function are isolated. Thus in these conditions (11,12), defective cybrids with mutant mtDNA from both young and aged subjects may have been excluded preferentially.Recently, to determine whether the mitochondrial or nuclear genome is responsible for mitochondrial diseases, we developed a system for delivery of a normal nuclear genome from 0 HeLa cells to fibroblasts from patients with respiration deficiency by isolating nuclear hybrids (13). In these nuclear hybrid clones, the nuclear genome was derived from both parental 0 HeLa cells and fibroblasts, whereas the mitochondrial genome is exclusively from fibroblasts.…”

“…However, the procedure for isolating cybrids by the transfer of fibroblast mtDNA to 0 cells is not appropriate for unambiguous determination of whether accumulation of mtDNA mutations is involved in age-related mitochondrial dysfunction, because during selection to exclude 0 cells using medium without uridine and/or pyruvate, cybrids expressing respiration deficiency due to accumulation of mtDNA mutations might also be eliminated preferentially, so that only cybrids with normal mitochondrial respiratory function are isolated. Thus in these conditions (11,12), defective cybrids with mutant mtDNA from both young and aged subjects may have been excluded preferentially.…”

Strikingly higher frequency in centenarians and twins of mtDNA mutation causing remodeling of replication origin in leukocytes

“…A similar relaxation of the copy number control, in this case produced by an inherited or somatic C150T mutation, may conceivably operate to accelerate mtDNA replication in centenarians and twins. It should be mentioned that a very significant decline with the donor's age in mtDNA content has been previously demonstrated in transformants constructed by transfer of mitochondria from fibroblasts of differently aged individuals into human mtDNA-less cells (24). An interesting possibility is that the somatic event(s) at or near position 150 leading to the appearance and͞or amplification of the C150T transition may be a part of a general remodeling of the mtDNA replication machinery, probably nuclearly controlled.…”