Cover crop mixtures did not out-yield the most productive single species plantings A 6-species cover crop mixture resulted in more stable cover crop yields across sites and years Grasses contributed greater biomass and more consistently to mixture production Kale productivity increased in the dry year making it a good choice for drier climates ABSTRACT Cover crops are a critical component of sustainable agroecosystems, yet their performance in semi-arid environments with short growing seasons and highly variable precipitation is inconsistent. To evaluate productivity and stability of single species vs. multi-species cover crop plantings with variable water input, cover crops were evaluated at two sites in North Dakota under dryland and dryland plus irrigation conditions. Cover crop treatments consisted of three warm-season monocultures, a three warm-season species mixture (MIX3), and a three warm-season and three cool-season species mixture (MIX6). Averaged across year and water regime, biomass production was not greater for mixtures (8693 kg ha -1 , MIX3; 10212 kg ha -1 , MIX6) than for the most productive monoculture (11295 kg ha -1 , sunflower) at the West site. The same held true at the East site (7486 kg ha -1 , MIX3; 8603 kg ha -1 , MIX6), with cowpea producing the most biomass, 10886 kg ha -1 , of all monocultures. At the West site, variability in production was lowest for MIX6 when pooled across year and water regime (CV = 25%) compared to monocultures (CV ≥ 49%). At the East site, cowpea had the lowest CV (24%) while mixtures averaged 35%. Pooled across sites, production in the MIX6 plots had the lowest variability (29%). Grasses consistently contributed to high proportions of total biomass production compared to other functional types. Multi-species cover crop mixtures are more versatile than single species plantings across climates, and resilient cover crop This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.mixtures integrated into semi-arid crop rotations as full season plantings should include warm and cool season grasses.