Thermal performance assessment and optimization for energy conversion and
utilization systems are of high significance in building energy efficiency.
Generally speaking, the evaluation of actual thermodynamic system
performance is mainly based on the first law of thermodynamics, with
emphasis on the quantity of energy consumption, while ignoring the energy
quality. Thus, it results in a one-sided evaluation in the analysis of
system energy saving. In this paper, the electricity equivalent is used to
analyze and evaluate the air source heat pump (ASHP) heating system under
the different working conditions. Moreover, the dynamic thermal performances
of three typical space heating devices (radiator, fan coil and radiant
floor) are investigated and compared by weighing both energy quantity and
quality. The results show that the COP of radiator, fan coil and are radiant
floor are 3.00, 3.82 and 4.76, and COEQ are 48.32%, 51.43% and 50.57%,
respectively. However, the robustness of its thermal performance is lower
than that of radiator and fan coil. This work can provide reference for
energy systems assessment and guidance for practical design of building
heating systems.