“…It follows that in case PWPV and, more broadly speaking, in the case of a uniform plane wave (1.3) scattering by an arbitrary flow with non-zero total circulation the RP is ill-posed. There is no contradiction because the total kinetic energy of an unbounded incompressible flow with as is hence it cannot exist, as noted by Reinschke et al (1997) and Gaifullin (2015, § III.1). In an unbounded three-dimensional fluid, only vortical structures with zero total circulation over any cross-section can emerge, such as the wake vortex behind an aeroplane with a high-aspect-ratio wing, which consists of two vortex tubes with opposite circulation, or the helicopter vortex ring.…”