Alcohol, Age, and Mortality: Estimating Selection Bias Due to Premature Death

Abstract

Alcohol use causes approximately 10% of deaths among adults ages 20-65 in the United States. Although previous research has demonstrated differential age-related risk relationships, it is difficult to estimate the magnitude of selection bias attributable to premature mortality based on existing cohort studies, the average age of which is greater than 50 years. The objective of our study was to assess the distribution of mortality-related harms and benefits from alcohol among adults ages 20 and older in comparison with the distribution among those older than age 50. Method: Data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's Alcohol-Related Disease Impact software application from 2006-10 were used to determine the distribution of alcohol-attributable deaths (AADs) and the years of potential life lost (YPLLs) that was caused or prevented by alcohol for 54 conditions by 15-year age groupings (20-34, 35-49, 50-64, 65+) in the United States. We also determined the proportion of net deaths and YPLLs occurring in each age group, overall and by cause of death. Results: Adults ages 20-49 years experienced 35.8% of the deaths and 58.4% of the YPLLs caused by alcohol, whereas the same group accrued only 4.5% of AADs and 14.2% of YPLLs gained. Overall, 46.3% of the total net deaths and 64.7% of the net YPLLs occurred among those ages 20-49; adding net deaths occurring among those ages 20-49 to those occurring after age 50 results in an 86.3% relative increase in net deaths. Conclusions: Because of premature mortality, alcohol-mortality associations based on cohort studies may underestimate negative health consequences compared with those among the general population. (J. Stud. Alcohol Drugs,

Association of alcohol consumption with morbidity and mortality in patients with cardiovascular disease: original data and meta-analysis of 48,423 men and women

“…The mean/median age at baseline was greater than 59 years in most datasets used in our analyses. Because alcohol-related risk is relatively higher among younger people compared with the elderly [ 68 ], enrolling older participants in studies would minimise the risk relationship compared with an analysis that included drinkers of all ages. Notably, with older age of the study participants comes increased likelihood for drinkers to become former drinkers, which might exacerbate the “sick quitters” bias (i.e.…”

Lifetime Drinking Trajectories and Nonfatal Acute Myocardial Infarction

“…The excess of early peak drinking trajectories among former drinkers in the present study provides support for this hypothesis. Harmful drinking patterns prior to age 35 represent not only an unassessed AMI risk, but also a potential source of selection bias since they may reduce study participation by individuals whose alcohol use has affected their well‐being (Naimi et al., ).…”

“…Irregular heavy drinking patterns, such as binge drinking, are most prevalent during adolescence and emerging adulthood (Lee and Sher, ), a period that may be completely overlooked in cohort studies that assess alcohol intake prospectively in subjects recruited when they are already entering middle age. Given that much alcohol‐related mortality takes place prior to the age at which participants enter most cohort studies, this may bias the enrollment of subjects at risk for alcohol‐related CHD (Naimi et al., ).…”

Alcohol control policies add to secular trends in all-cause mortality rates in young adults

“…In younger age groups, alcohol consumption is more likely to be characterized by heavy episodic drinking (HED), which has high (40–45%) prevalence rates among young adolescents (15–24 years old 12 ). In young and middle-aged adults (15–49 years old), alcohol consumption is also a leading risk factor for premature death, whereas other risk factors, such as smoking and high BMI cause greater loss of life among older adults 16 – 18 . In one study, traffic accidents had a greater proportion of victims with blood alcohol levels > 10 mg/dl for adults 34 years of age and younger, compared to other adult age groups (35–74 years old) 19 .…”