Alcohol Screening Questionnaires in Women

Abstract

Objective.-To describe the performance of alcohol screening questionnaires in female patients.Data Sources.-We searched MEDLINE from 1966 to July 1997 for alcoholism or alcohol-drinking and for CAGE, AUDIT, BMAST, TWEAK, T-ACE, MAST, SMAST, or SAAST; Citations Indexes for newer screening questionnaires and those without acronyms; and MEDLINE from 1996 to July 1997 for alcoholism or alcohol-drinking and screening.Study Selection and Data Extraction.-Reviewed studies presented data for women comparing brief alcohol screening questionnaires with valid criterion standards for heavy drinking (Ն2 drinks per day) or alcohol abuse or dependence in US general clinical populations. Sensitivities, specificities, and areas under receiver operating characteristic curves (AUROCs) were extracted.Data Synthesis.-Thirteen articles (9 studies) were reviewed. The CAGE questionnaire had AUROCs of 0.84 to 0.92 for alcohol abuse and dependence in predominantly black populations of women, but using the traditional cut point of 2 or more resulted in low sensitivities (38%-50%) in predominantly white female populations. The TWEAK and Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test (AUDIT) questionnaires had high AUROCs (0.87-0.93) for past-year alcohol abuse or dependence in black or white women, but had sensitivities less than 80% at traditional cut points. For detecting heavy drinking, the AUDIT questionnaire had AUROCs of at least 0.87 in female primary care patients. The TWEAK and T-ACE questionnaires had higher AUROCs (0.84-0.87) than the CAGE questionnaire (0.76-0.78) for detecting heavy drinking before pregnancy was recognized in black obstetric patients.Conclusions.-The CAGE questionnaire was relatively insensitive in predominantly white female populations. The TWEAK and AUDIT questionnaires have performed adequately in black or white women, using lower cut points than usual.

Posttraumatic Stress Disorder, Health Problems, and Depression Among African American Women in Residential Substance Use Treatment

“…For alcohol, brief screeners such as the TWEAK 41 were developed specifically for pregnant women. For other drugs, tools like the CAGE 42,43 have been studied in women, yet neither measure is used routinely in clinical practice. Similarly, it is important to identify practical ways to screen atrisk treatment seeking women who might potentially benefit from trauma-focused services.…”

Does Stage of Change Predict Improved Intimate Partner Violence Outcomes Following an Emergency Department Intervention?

“…2 was used to identify alcohol abusers in our study. This cut point has been suggested by several studies as being the most appropriate cut point to use for females 17 and for patients in the ED. 18 The TWEAK scale was shown to perform well among African American women, with high sensitivity, using these cut points in comparison to other measurement tools, such as the CAGE.…”

“…18 The TWEAK scale was shown to perform well among African American women, with high sensitivity, using these cut points in comparison to other measurement tools, such as the CAGE. 17 The Drug Abuse Screening Test (DAST-10)…”

Exiting Shelter: An Epidemiological Analysis of Barriers and Facilitators for Families

“…3 Also used to screen for harmful drinking in general household samples (Chan et al 1993), the test is found to be highly predictive of alcohol abuse and dependence in racially mixed populations (Bradley et al 1998;Cherpitel 1999). The maximum score on the test is 7 points; a total score of 2 or more on the test indicates harmful drinking and the need for further evaluation (O'Connor and Whaley 2003).…”