This work is focused on the optimal sizing of fan-supplied tube-fin evaporators for light commercial refrigerators operating under frosting conditions. Quasi-steady-state algebraic models were put forward for the refrigeration cycle and its components for computing not only the cooling capacity depletion due to the evaporator frosting over time, but also the changes experienced by the evaporating temperature and its effect on the compression power. Transient algebraic models were also advanced to account for the temperature and humidity variations inside the refrigerated compartment, and so the compressor runtime. Both component-level and system-level optimization exercises were performed for sizing the evaporator. The former was focused on the local entropy generation minimization, considering the irreversibilities due to heat transfer, mass transfer and pressure drop that take place at the evaporator, whereas the latter was aimed at the overall energy consumption of the refrigerator, including not only the compression power, but also the heat dissipation within the refrigerated compartment by the defrost heater and the evaporator fan. Notwithstanding the time-averaged cooling capacity and the evaporator envelope have been held constrained, the component-level and the system-level optimization procedures led to different evaporator designs.