Alternate indices of electric and magnetic field exposures among Ontario electrical utility workers

Abstract

Epidemiologic studies examining the risk of cancer among occupational groups exposed to electric fields (EF) and or magnetic fields (MF) have relied on traditional summaries of exposure such as the time weighted arithmetic or geometric mean exposure. Findings from animal and cellular studies support the consideration of alternative measures of exposure capable of capturing threshold and intermittent measures of field strength. The main objective of this study was to identify a series of suitable exposure metrics for an ongoing cancer incidence study in a cohort of Ontario electric utility workers. Principal components analysis (PCA) and correlational analysis were used to explore the relationships within and between series of EF and MF exposure indices. Exposure data were collected using personal monitors worn by a sample of 820 workers which yielded 4247 worker days of measurement data. For both EF and MF, the first axis of the PCA identified a series of intercorrelated indices that included the geometric mean, median and arithmetic mean. A considerable portion of the variability in EF and MF exposures were accounted for by two other principal component axes. The second axes for EF and MF exposures were representative of the standard deviation (standard deviation) and thresholds of field measures. To a lesser extent, the variability in the exposure variable was explained by time dependent indices which consisted of autocorrelations at 5 min lags and average transitions in field strength. Our results suggest that the variability in exposure data can only be accounted for by using several exposure indices, and consequently, a series of metrics should be used when exploring the risk of cancer owing to MF and EF exposure in this cohort. Furthermore, the poor correlations observed between indices of MF and EF reinforce the need to be take both fields into account when assessing the risk of cancer in this occupational group. Bioelectromagnetics 19:140–151, 1998. © 1998 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.

Non-Hodgkin's lymphoma among electric utility workers in Ontario: the evaluation of alternate indices of exposure to 60 Hz electric and magnetic fields

“…The relation between NHL and the cumulative TWA based on the geometric and arithmetic mean exposure in this study population has previously been reported 8. However, recent analyses to correlate the exposure data indicated that the use of the arithmetic and geometric means, by themselves, does not adequately characterise the variability of exposures to either electric or magnetic fields 42. The correlation analysis also suggested that alternate indices of exposure—such as the SD of field strength, the percentage of time above a threshold, and fluctuations of field strength over successive time intervals—should be evaluated when examining the relations between field exposure and cancer within this study population.…”

Future needs of occupational epidemiology of extremely low frequency electric and magnetic fields: review and recommendations

“…Multivariable statistical techniques93 – 97 may also be useful in analysing multiple exposure metrics obtained by using measurement data from vector waveform monitors 97 – 99…”

Exposure to electromagnetic fields and suicide among electric utility workers: a nested case-control study

“…23 Assignment of exposure to magnetic fields Workers in the electric utility industry have complicated patterns of exposure to EMFs, with several possible measurements, including transient measures of magnetic and electric fields. 24,25 Exposure to EMFs was estimated by an assessment of exposure to magnetic fields, focusing on the time-weighted average, as described in detail elsewhere and briefly summarized here. 19,[26][27][28] Complete work histories were abstracted and computerized.…”