Alternating between active and passive facilitator roles in simulated scenarios: a qualitative study of nursing students’ perceptions

Abstract

Background High-fidelity simulation refers to realistic interactivity between students and an advanced simulator. During simulated scenarios, the facilitator often needs to provide guidance to the active students to bridge the gap between their insufficient practical nursing skills and clinical learning needs. Facilitators’ guidance should support students in problem-solving and help them progress in their simulation experiences. The aim of this study was to explore and describe nursing students´ perspectives on the facilitator’s role during simulated scenarios. Methods A qualitative design was used. Thirty-two nursing students participated in five focus groups conducted immediately after a 2-day high-fidelity simulation course in the second year of their Bachelor of Nursing in Norway. The analysis used structured text condensation. Results One main category, “Alternating between active and passive facilitation,” emerged along with three sub-categories: (1) practical support: the facilitator played an important role in ensuring the flow of the simulated scenarios. Some students sought cues from the facilitator or responses to their actions. Other students wanted to act independently, reassured by the possibility of asking for assistance. (2) Guiding communication: the facilitator was important to students in paving their way to achieve the learning outcomes. The way facilitators supported students influenced students’ understanding and their feelings about how they handled the situation and whether they achieved the learning outcomes. (3) Emotional influence: the facilitator’s presence in the simulation room during the simulated scenarios influenced students’ emotions, for example having a calming or aggravating effect or making them feel distressed. In some cases, students were undisturbed. Conclusions The facilitation of simulated scenarios requires special skills in providing individually suitable cues at the right time to students with a variety of learning preferences. It is vital that facilitators have well-developed relational, pedagogical, and emotional competence combined with clinical, technical, and simulation-based learning skills in monitoring different learning preferences. As the facilitator role is challenging and complicated, more research is needed to explore how facilitators could monitor and adjust cues individually in simulated scenarios.

Exploring intensive care nurses' perception of simulation‐based learning: A systematic review and meta‐synthesis

“…However, the effectiveness of debriefing can vary depending on the skill and experience of the facilitator, highlighting the need for comprehensive training (Guerrero, Ali, & Attallah, 2022; Guerrero, Tungpalan‐Castro, & Pingue‐Raguini, 2022). Facilitating SBL requires diverse skills, including relational, pedagogical, emotional, clinical, technical and SBL abilities (Solli et al., 2022). Facilitators must be able to adjust cues individually to accommodate different learning styles.…”

An Exploratory Study of Issues in Training Facilitators for Online Training in Advance Care Planning: Mixed Methods Research

“…As the facilitators’ learning support abilities play an important role in simulation education [ 17 ], it is important to standardize the facilitators’ learning support abilities. Facilitators must appropriately understand the needs of the learners and respond flexibly [ 24 ].…”

Experiences of the nursing student in learning HAI prevention and control in Asian countries through the use of scenario-based simulation: an explorative qualitative study

“…Additionally, the simulations provided opportunities for students to engage in discussions and receive feedback from instructors and observers for improving both clinical and non-technical skills. Similarly, Solli et al (2022) suggested that it is essential to create a trusted learning environment for students with dynamic interaction and collaboration. Such an environment would contribute to fostering a learner-centered perspective.…”