America's Machiavellian: Gouverneur Morris at the Constitutional Convention

Abstract

While generally a steady ally of James Madison and the nationalists, Gouverneur Morris, delegate from Pennsylvania, worked from a different conception of republican politics. Morris's republicanism was more old than new, relying on the divided sovereignty of a mixed regime to protect the rights of citizens and minorities. This conception, it is argued here, bears the stamp of Machiavelli, especially regarding the relationship of the classes and the role of the executive. Like Machiavelli—but unlike Madison—Morris wanted to underscore society's class divisions, organizing the representatives of rich and poor into two distinct, and hostile, chambers of the legislature. And like Machiavelli, whose “civil prince” was the champion of the people, Morris's executive was to be the “guardian of the people” and the “guardian of liberty.”

Philadelphia reconsidered: participant curation, the Gerry Committee, and US constitutional design

“…Some investigate the dimensionality of debate as a method for uncovering meaning (Dougherty & Heckelman, 2006;Jillson, 2002;Roche, 1961;Rossiter, 1987). Many accounts emphasize delegates' backgrounds, religious and ideological views, and rhetoric (Beard, 1913;Coby, 2017Coby, , 2018Dougherty & Heckelman, 2008;Hall, 2012;McDonald, 1958).…”