An AHP/DEA hybrid model for measuring the relative efficiency of energy efficiency technologies

Lee, S.K.; Mogi, Gento; Shin, Sang-Hoon; Kim, J.W.

doi:10.1109/ieem.2007.4419150

Cited by 11 publications

(8 citation statements)

References 7 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…The RI values from 1 to 10 are shown in Table 3. If the CR value is less than 0.10, the comparisons of the decision makers are considered to be satisfactorily consistent; if not, they are inconsistent, which indicates that the AHP has not produced significant results (Lee, Mogi, Shin, & Kim, 2007). In another study, Saaty (1996) proposed 5% and 8% as thresholds for 3x3 and 4x4 matrices, respectively while keeping a 10% threshold for larger matrices.…”

Section: Literature Reviewmentioning

confidence: 99%

Comparison of Two Different Judgment Scales With the Ahp GSM Operator Preference of University Students

Canhasi-Kasemi¹,

Vardari²

2023

IJAHP

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) is a method with elegant mathematical features that is widely used in multi-criteria decision making. One of the main applications of this method, which is frequently preferred by decision makers due to its systematic and understandable structure, includes addressing inadequacies in terms of numerical scales that are generally used in pairwise comparisons. Therefore, this study includes two different judgment scales, Saaty’s fundamental scale and the Balanced scale, which were used in the pairwise comparison stage. After the comparisons were made, the variance related to the consistency ratios and the range of the sensitivity was also observed. In the study, we discuss the use of both judgment scales in a real problem and their effects on priority estimation in the AHP. The study's goal is to evaluate the outcomes of Saaty’s fundamental scale and the Balanced scale in the AHP technique for the two current operators in Kosovo's GSM sector, VALA and IPKO, and assess the preference of students in Kosovo. The required data were obtained through a questionnaire and the importance weights of the decision criteria were calculated separately for each scale and compared. The preference order of the GSM operators was discovered according to each decision criterion and all criteria. The ranking of the weights obtained with both scales resulted in IPKO first, followed by VALA. The Balanced scale made the results lighter in the weight distribution. Another important result is that the pairwise comparisons made with the Balanced scale yielded results that are more sensitive. In addition, the closeness of the priority vectors obtained with both scales according to Saaty’s compatibility index and Garuti’s compatibility index was examined.

show abstract

Section: Literature Reviewmentioning

confidence: 99%

Comparison of Two Different Judgment Scales With the Ahp GSM Operator Preference of University Students

Canhasi-Kasemi¹,

Vardari²

2023

IJAHP

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…A consistency value of up to 0.10 in the consistency ratio (CR) is acceptable. A CR value greater than 10% indicates that the decision maker should review its decisions [5].…”

Section: Analytic Hierarchy Process -Ahpmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…Stern et al [4], concluded that DMUs, which have more Financial efficiency of companies operating in the Kosovo food sector: DEA and DEAHP 129 than one input and output, used a two-stage method with AHP to make complete sequencing whereas the DEA method lacked. In 2007 Lee et al [5], the AHP and DEA hybrid approach in their studies and applied in the national energy efficiency plan sector. For the selection of warehouse operator networks, Korpela et al [6], combined AHP and DEA methods.…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

Financial efficiency of companies operating in the Kosovo food sector: DEA and DEAHP

Kasemi¹

2022

Int. J. Optim. Control, Theor. Appl. (IJOCTA)

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) evaluates a large number of input and output variables using mathematical programming techniques and analyzes the effectiveness of similar decision making units (DMU). Unlike traditional methods, the most important advantage of DEA is that the weights of input and output variables can be defined by the analyzer. In this study, the limitations of the DEA weights were determined using the AHP, which considers expert opinion. In addition, an alternative judgment scale was used for the Saaty judgment scale, which is used as a standard in the AHP method, and thus a more sensitive analysis was performed. There have been studies dealing with the comparison of judgment scales, but few studies on consistency sensitivity are needed. This point has also been addressed in this study. Subsequently, the financial efficiency of 27 companies operating in the food sector in Kosovo was evaluated with the weight-restricted DEA model, first created using the unweighted DEA model and then the AHP model, and the two models were compared. This paper is the first one of its kind since there are no previous studies regarding the examination of the financial efficiency of companies operating in the Kosovo food sector based on the DEAHP method.

show abstract

“…RI values from 1 to 10 is shown in Table 2. If CR value is less than 0,10, the comparisons of decision makers are considered to be consistent at satisfactory levels; if not, it is noted to be inconsistent, which indicates that AHP can't produce significant results [2].…”

Section: 4 6 8 Intermediate Valuesmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…There are a large number of studies conducted by using either DEA or AHP models. To name a few examples conducted with the integrated model; [1] researchers suggested a two step model for organizations with multiple inputs and outputs in studies conducted with (DEAHP) integrated model: in the first step the data are analyzed with DEA and in the second with AHP; [2] the researchers measured relative efficiency of energy efficiency technologies in the national energy efficiency plan sector by using AHP and DEA integrated models. In practice, CCR model used to be conducted to assess outputs while this new approach indicated that AHP and DEA integrated model can be an ideal model for the solution of multi-criteria decision making problems in the energy sector; [3] the researchers conducted a study on the choice of warehouse operator network by combining DEA and AHP models; [4] a study was conducted on the suppliers for BEKO company, which analyzed the data by using AHP model and then the same data by using DEAHP integrated model; [5] the researchers evaluated the risks of different bridge designs by using DEA/AHP integrated model to evaluate criteria (with AHP model) and to determine the values (with DEA model); [6] in a study on the efficiency of notebooks in a wide range of brands and models, the variable returns to scale (BCC) model was used by using EMS package program to analyze 2 different efficiency analyses; this first analysis was conducted with DEA model and the second analysis was conducted after adding weights to DEA model with the help of AHP model; [7] the researchers enlisted the activities of local governments in China using the DEA and AHP integrated model; [8] a study was also conducted to evaluate the efficiency of 26 public hospitals in Ankara with 4 input variables and 5 output variables.…”

Section: Introduction and Literature Reviewmentioning

confidence: 99%

Evaluation of the Efficiencies of Public High Schools in Izmir/Turkey Using Deahp Approach

Ayna¹,

Gültekin²

2019

Anadolu University Journal of Science and Technology-a Applied Sciences and Engineering

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

This study is carried out to assess the relative efficiency of the Anatolian high schools in İzmir /Turkey and to guide inefficient educational institutions to become efficient. Firstly, efficiency measurement is performed by Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) model. Instead of assigning equal weights to the input and output variables, the analysis is repeated by assigning weights with the aid of the Analytic Hierarchy Process(AHP) model. 3 input and 3 output variables are determined in the study and 47 Anatolian High Schools are analyzed. In İzmir, this study is important since it is the first study to assess the efficiency of Anatolian high schools with Data Envelopment Analytic Hierarchy Process (DEAHP) integrated model.

show abstract

An AHP/DEA hybrid model for measuring the relative efficiency of energy efficiency technologies

Cited by 11 publications

References 7 publications

Comparison of Two Different Judgment Scales With the Ahp GSM Operator Preference of University Students

Comparison of Two Different Judgment Scales With the Ahp GSM Operator Preference of University Students

Financial efficiency of companies operating in the Kosovo food sector: DEA and DEAHP

Evaluation of the Efficiencies of Public High Schools in Izmir/Turkey Using Deahp Approach

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About