Recently, we proposed a spectrum-sharing paradigm for single-carrier cognitive radio (CR) networks, where a secondary user (SU) is able to maintain or even improve the performance of a primary user (PU) transmission, while also obtaining a low-data rate channel for its own communication. According to such a scheme, a simple multiplication is used to superimpose one SU symbol on a block of multiple PU symbols. The scope of this paper is to extend such a paradigm to a multicarrier CR network, where the PU employs an orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing (OFDM) modulation scheme. To improve its achievable data rate, besides transmitting over the subcarriers unused by the PU, the SU is also allowed to transmit multiple block-precoded symbols in parallel over the OFDM subcarriers used by the primary system. Specifically, the SU convolves its block-precoded symbols with the received PU data in the timedomain, which gives rise to the term convolutive superposition. An information-theoretic analysis of the proposed scheme is developed, which considers different amounts of network state information at the secondary transmitter, as well as different precoding strategies for the SU. Extensive simulations illustrate the merits of our analysis and designs, in comparison with conventional CR schemes, by considering as performance indicators the ergodic capacity of the considered systems.