An analysis of question asking on scientific texts explaining natural phenomena

Abstract

This article relays results of a study focused on questions invoked to correct declarative knowledge deficits while readers process science texts explaining natural phenomena. Firstly, the authors focused on finding out what kind of questions are asked by students who read these texts and, secondly how task demand influences quantity and quality of formulated questions. Two hundred and eighty nine Portuguese students from 8th, 10th, and 12th grade participated in the study. The students were instructed to ask questions on two short science paragraphs that explained natural phenomena. Three task conditions were chosen. Thus, in the “Class” condition, the task was introduced as an activity aimed at developing the capacity to ask questions. In the “Examination” condition, the task was presented as a test on question generation. Finally, in the “Extra‐academic” condition the questioning task was camouflaged as a participation in a research project sponsored by the Ministry of Education and geared at the improvement of science textbooks. The results have shown that students are able to ask many questions when given an opportunity to do so. The study has also proven that students are capable of generating a large volume of causal‐antecedent questions relative to this kind of texts. Finally, no clear effects were found between grade level and/or task demand as defined in the conducted study. © 2000 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Res Sci Teach 37: 602–614, 2000

Supporting Argumentation Through Students' Questions: Case Studies in Science Classrooms

“…However, most of the studies carried out to date on teaching students questioning have been for the purpose of improving reading comprehension of text (e.g., Costa, Caldeira, Gallástegui, & Otero, 2000;Koch & Eckstein, 1991), generating researchable questions for science investigations (Cuccio-Schirripa & Steiner, 2000;Hofstein et al, 2005), or guiding project work (Pedrosa de Jesus, Neri de Souza, Teixiera-Dias, & Watts, 2005). Little, if any, research has been reported on teaching or scaffolding students in questioning in which the goal is to develop students' skills in argumentation or reasoning about issues for which multiple perspectives have to be considered.…”

Questions About Physics: The Case of a Turkish ‘Ask a Scientist’ Website

“…Although generating questions is useful for students and teachers who use these questions, the findings from research studies have indicated that students are generally unwilling to ask questions. However, many studies have revealed that students could ask meaningful, valuable, critical, and more questions when the opportunity is given to them (Colbert et al 2007;Costa et al 2000;Dori and Herscovitz 1999;Harper et al 2003;Hofstein et al 2005;Marbach-Ad and Sokolove 2000).…”

“…On the other hand, such inventories are generally restricted to the specific focus producing only a limited view of what may or may not be formative about attitudes to science. Furthermore, a great deal of research studies have focused on students' questions in classroom settings Chin and Kayalvizhi 2002;Colbert et al 2007;Costa et al 2000;Dahlgren and Öberg 2001;de Jesus et al 2003;Harper et al 2003;Hofstein et al 2005;Marbach-Ad and Sokolove 2000). However, there is little known about students' questions produced outside of the classroom settings.…”

Effect of Strategy Instruction on Fourth-Grade Dual Language Learners' Ability to Monitor Their Comprehension of Scientific Texts

“…In science self-monitoring takes the form of reflection in action. Questioning is a regulation action (Costa, Caldeira, Gallástegui, & Otero, 2000). Generating questions is one of the characteristics of inquiry-based science, while in reading asking questions helps comprehension (NRP, 2000).…”