An Approach for Integrating and Analyzing Sustainability in Food-Based Dietary Guidelines

Abstract

International organizations, governments, researchers, and activists have proposed the need for deeper integration of sustainability considerations in national food-based dietary guidelines (FBDGs). Yet, as recent scholarship advances the conversation, questions remain around how to effectively frame and address the interconnectedness of multiple sustainability domains. Little systematic analysis has evaluated how current FBDGs have integrated complex messages about socially, environmentally, and economically sustainable consumption practices with nutrition and health messages. This study had two nested objectives: (i) to examine the validity of an existing sustainable diets framework by assessing how sustainability concepts have been framed and included in national FBDGs available from 2011 to 2019 and (ii) to describe a novel analysis approach that augments an existing framework which integrates sustainability domains and can be adapted for use by future FBDGs. A qualitative content analysis was used to examine sustainability concepts found in 12 FBDGs and supporting documents available in English that were developed for use in 16 countries across Europe, North and South America, and Asia as of 2019—from a global review of those published prior to 2016 and gray literature review of publications between 2016 and 2019. Health domains were the primary frame found across the FBDGs examined, but documents also commonly incorporated agricultural, sociocultural, and economic sustainability principles. Analyzed documents were used to adapt an existing policy analysis framework into a “Sustainability in FBDGs Framework.” This proposed framework contributes a novel analysis approach and has five core domains that are interconnected: health and nutrition, food security and agriculture, markets and value chains, sociocultural and political, and environment and ecosystems. This study adds to the growing body of literature related to sustainable food systems and dietary guidelines by presenting how sustainability framing in FBDGs can be used to further develop a comprehensive framework for integrating sustainability domains. While this project helps to validate previous work, further analyses of FBDGs which have emerged since this study and those not available in English are needed to improve the guidance approach described here and for assessing the incorporation of sustainability domains in future FBDGs. This work is useful in informing processes for policy developers to integrate sustainability considerations into their national FBDGs.

Systematic Studies on the Antioxidant Capacity and Volatile Compound Profile of Yellow Mealworm Larvae (T. molitor L.) under Different Drying Regimes

“…Current food production systems will not be able to sustainably supply the projected world population with conventional animal protein, especially in the face of climate change [2][3][4]. Animal proteins require more natural resources to be produced, so future food capacities at medium levels of animal-based agriculture are much more desirable from a nutritional as well as sustainability perspective [5,6]. Insects have received attention as a sustainable, macro-and micronutrient-rich food and feed resource over the past 10 years [7][8][9].…”

Basics of Sustainable Diets and Tools for Assessing Dietary Sustainability: A Primer for Researchers and Policy Actors

“…According to Springmann [ 95 ] and Kovacs [ 96 ], however, the current food-based dietary guidelines are incompatible with climate change, freshwater, land use, and nitrogen targets, and this should be corrected. As a result, the FAO and several individual researchers have pledged the incorporation of sustainability in the national and global dietary guidelines [ 95 , 97 , 98 ]. According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, every country needs to evaluate how land and natural resources can be used for food production in the most sustainable manner, and consider socio-economic, natural site-specific, and cultural particularities of each geographic area before making suggestions for a sustainable diet policy [ 99 ].…”

The grammar of monitoring and enforcement mechanisms in international conservation: A comparative institutional analysis of four treaty regimes

“…Discrepancies were discussed with an IG‐coding expert with coding adjustments made based on the guidance provided. Such a “single knowledgeable coder approach” facilitates reproducibility by “other similarly knowledgeable coders apply[ing] the same method” (Campbell et al, 2013; Mazac et al, 2021, p. 5) and is appropriate for research that aims to gain a complex understanding of the data instead of quantitative reliability measurements (Syed & Nelson, 2015).…”