The presence of H2O has
been linked to enhancements
in the reactivity of cathodes for Mg2+ electrochemistry.
If the enhancements were mimicked by nonaqueous solvents, they could
enable Mg batteries with transformational energy density. However,
the extent to which H2O may boost actual intercalation
of Mg2+, as opposed to competing reactions, has not been
elucidated. Here, we evaluate its role as additive in the electrochemistry
of a tunnel polymorph of V2O5 in a nonaqueous
Mg2+ electrolyte. The electrochemical response and V reduction
in the cathodes positively correlated with H2O concentration,
but it was not concurrent with commensurate changes in cell volume
and Mg content. These observations indicate that H2O does
not enhance Mg2+ intercalation, but rather, it promotes
competing pathways. This work shows the importance of accurately probing
reactions in multivalent electrolytes. Importantly, it indicates that
H2O is not a universal solution to the challenge of Mg2+ intercalation in oxides.