An empirical analysis of SMES’ triple bottom line practices

Abstract

Purpose This study aims to examine the determinants of small and medium enterprises (SMEs) sustainability practices in New Zealand from the triple bottom line (3BL) perspective. Unlike large companies and government agencies whose sustainability practices are driven by regulations and attempts to legitimise business operations, little is known about the drivers of SMEs’ sustainability practices. Design/methodology/approach A cross-sectional survey approach was adopted for the data collection. The analysis was mainly descriptive, while the covariates’ effects were measured based on partial least squares structural equation modelling. Findings This paper identified that SMEs’ 3BL practices are significantly influenced by local bylaws, voluntary adoption of 3BL operational policies and company size. This paper finds that the SMEs’ industry type is not statistically significant as a determinant of their 3BL practices. This implies that regulation and operational policies increase sustainability practices in the SME sector. Practical implications These findings provide insights to SMEs’ managers on the importance of sustainability policies adoption and bylaws. Government departments and local government councils could adopt the findings in developing regulatory policies that support SMEs’ 3BL. Social implications This study provides support for economically, environmentally and socially sustainable business practices amongst SMEs. Originality/value A dearth of studies on SMEs sustainability practices exists in the extant literature, particularly in New Zealand. The study focusses on SMEs sustainability in the viewpoint of 3BL practices based on an empirical analysis.

From conceptual model to conceptual framework: A sustainable business framework for community water supply businesses

“…Examines how the actions of each firm or organization may have a beneficial effect on the economy, society, and environment. This is the world's long-term sustainability from the perspective of business (Edeigba and Arasanmi, 2022). provides a detailed analysis of the "triple bottom line."…”

Hungarian entrepreneurs’ sustainability motivations based on GEM 2021 results

“…A sustainability focus can benefit SMEs by enabling them to create competitive networks, become investment destinations and valuable actors in global supply chains (Moore and Manring, 2009). The SME sector can also be a breakthrough in solving environmental and social problems and making business more sustainable, given this sector's economic and social importance (Hall et al, 2010) As for what motivates SMEs towards sustainability, research shows that triple bottom line (3BL) practices are facilitated by local bylaws, the voluntary adoption of 3BL operational policies and company size (Edeigba and Arasanmi, 2022). However, other research projects suggest that stakeholders close to SMEs can have a positive effect, while external regulation has the opposite effect and tends to provoke resistance (Ernst et al, 2022).…”

Is Innovation a Driver of Sustainability? An Analysis from a Spanish Region

“…In 1997, Elkington published his popular book "Cannibals With Forks", with which he set out his "triple bottom line" (TBL) model, a translation of the three sustainable development pillars to the business environment [54]. The 'bottom line' of a corporation is complimented by bottom lines for socio-environmental performance, "termed 'people, planet, profit', encouraging firms to consider longer-term perspectives in their decision making" [9,54]. Although the model has been criticized for being vague and confusing, Elkington's TBL has become popular in the business world.…”

“…The economic bottom line focuses on an entity's financial aspect, such as "sales growth, profit growth, return on equity, return on asset and gearing" [56]. Social bottom-line sustainability includes employees, consumers and the host community [9,57]. Thus, the economic dimension measures the financial performance of an entity, while the other two dimensions require the entity to leverage its profits for the community, including social welfare and the prevention of environmental damage [58].…”

“…A Spanish area, Comunidad Valenciana (Valencian Community), which is large enough to be studied, was selected for this work and a statistical analysis was applied to extrapolate our conclusions. Our focus lay on small-and medium-sized enterprises (SME), which represent more than 99% of European enterprises, and 90% of the world's companies, produce around 60% of overall manufacturing and services turnover, and employ almost 70% of the European and world workforce [7][8][9]. Their contribution to pollution is estimated at 60-70% of the world's pollution [10], and some experiences suggest that environmental support programs do not work with SMEs, given lack of related knowledge and time to implement them [11].…”