An Empirical Revision of the Definition of Science Fiction: It Is All in the Techne . . .

Abstract

Researchers employ science fiction and fantasy in public engagement, advocacy, and education as significant sources of insights to identify public interests, inspire public policy, and influence future science. These uses of science fiction as a source that is expected to reflect public interests are undermined if the examples employed by researchers are interpreted differently by the intended audience or beneficiaries of research. We surveyed the public to identify their definitions and discovered a categorization based on clearly defined features. These align with some academic theories but differ from postmodern approaches as the analysis suggests science fiction can be defined categorically. The empirical survey data are consistent and demonstrate an unmistakable distinction between popular definitions of science fiction and fantasy. Our theoretical analysis implies some definitions may be confused by evaluating secondary “fuzzy” characteristics as if they were fundamental features of the genre. We suggest Wittgenstein’s family resemblances, between subjects associated with the genre at any specific time, should be interpreted as an ephemeral grouping validated by correlation with enduring core features, rather than definitive. On the basis of the common themes identified from the survey responses and a critique of existing genre models, we suggest the classical concept of techne may best describe the empirical essence of science fiction. Researchers intending to employ science fiction for applications that have an influence in the public realm may wish to consider this when designing their research.

Virtual Reality and Alternate Realities in Neal Stephenson’s “Snow Crash”

“…Well and Jules Verne influenced American authors like Edgar Rice Burroughs and H.P. Lovecraft, who helped shape the genre with their imaginative tales of otherworldly adventures and cosmic horror (Menadue et al, 2020).…”

Examining the superpower-based representation of eating disorder illness and recovery with data mining of The Art of Starving

“…The elements that differentiate fantasy books from those of other genres, their magical and/or supernatural elements, could be what in uences their therapeutic e cacy (32). The belief that a ction book's therapeutic e cacy depends on maximizing the extent to which a ctional character is similar to a reader has dominated literature (33).…”

“…This paradigm assumes maximizing character-reader similarity to promote identi cation with the character, providing the self-insight needed to engage in problem-solving action (33). This indicates a decreased therapeutic potential of fantasy books because they contain magical and/or supernatural elements (32).…”

El cine en el aprendizaje de la manipulación genética a través de ciencia ficción en Gattaca (1997)

“…Esto incluye lo fantástico, el horror y la vertiente de fantasía» 8 . A diferencia de algunos autores contemporáneos, quienes aducen que la ciencia ficción comenzó con Mary Shelley y Frankenstein en 1918 9 , Westfahl argumenta que la ciencia ficción fue fundada por Hugo Gernsback en 1926, quien la definió como «un romance encantador entremezclado con hechos científicos y visión profética» 10 .…”