An examination of nurse‐authored patents: Implications for nursing practice

Abstract

Background Recognition for medical inventions and innovations is largely associated with physician‐researchers, scientists, and engineers. The term “nurse” is largely absent from patents awarded in the United States. Yet, as front‐line healthcare providers, who better to add to the current population of inventors and innovators of new, meaningful scientific and engineering medical discoveries than specialized advanced practice nurses and their registered nurse colleagues? Although medical inventions and innovations are not entirely new activities for nurses, the authors speculate that greater opportunities exist for these healthcare professionals to lead in and be officially recognized for medical care discoveries and advancements by having their names on patents awarded. Also, we surmise that without the active and dedicated participation of nurses, important and significant discoveries may be missed. Aims The purpose of this paper is to address the importance of having nurses at all levels and specialties engaged in healthcare inventions and innovations. The foundation for this thesis begins by describing the findings from the first quantitative analysis of nurses' participation and/or recognition for the invention and innovation of medical devices and instruments, defined by having their names on awarded United States patents. In addition, we identify meaningful pathways for nurses to engage in this space. Methods Data to evaluate nurse participation and recognition for medical device and instrument inventions and innovations were collected through a publicly accessible website, the United States Patent and Trademark Office database, and analyzed with respect to whether the patent author(s) were nurses or nonnurses. Results More than 65 000 patents were identified with the terms “medical device” and “medical instrument.” From the 65 000+ patent‐population, 100 random patents were analyzed for the purposes of this first study and none were determined to have a nurse listed as a participating inventor or innovator. As a result of this analysis, the authors: (a) identify that nurses are largely unrecognized in the medical device invention and innovation space and (b) create models that explain nurses' engagement in this space from (i) historical and contemporary perspectives and (ii) for enhanced future involvement in healthcare patent activities. The future model is especially important as it provides a pathway for nurses to enhance their inventive and innovative competencies, effectiveness, and efficiency through new professional roles, additional education, creation of new educational programs, and formation of professional collaborations. It also calls for organizations that employ nurses to overtly allocate time, resources, and support for invention and innovation activities. We posit that fostering and facilitating nurses to enter the medical invention and innovation space stimulates discoveries that can improve patient care experiences, operations, and outcomes, reduce healthcare costs and provide...

Nurses’ confidence in starting a new venture, startup or project in the context of nurse-led hackathons: Results of prehackathon survey

“…Although nurses and nursing students are not traditionally taught innovation, business and entrepreneurial skills, many often ideate solutions to daily work challenges. Despite representing one of the largest workforce segments in health care, nurses are credited with the least number of patents, documented discoveries, and the ability to view themselves as innovators ( Davis & Glasgow, 2020 ). We deduced that nurses and nursing students did not view themselves as innovators and lacked a higher level of confidence conducive to the challenges and difficulties involved in business venture startup.…”

Kirkpatrick's evaluation of the effect of a nursing innovation team training for clinical nurses

“…Meanwhile, a recent study found that the term "nurse" was largely absent from patents awarded in the United States (Davis & Glasgow, 2020). The innovative capabilities of nurses can help to improve patient care experiences, practices and outcomes, reduce health care costs and outcomes (Davis & Glasgow, 2020), and produce personal benefits and organizational operational performance (Moreira M R A et al, 2017). Therefore, there is an urgent need to develop and train the innovative capabilities of nurses.…”

“…However, previous studies have found that nurses had varying levels of innovative behaviours (Bunpin et al, 2016; Liu, 2019; Sönmez & Yıldırım, 2019), moderate level of innovation ability (Jiang et al, 2020), and average level of innovation outputs (Sönmez et al, 2019). Meanwhile, a recent study found that the term “nurse” was largely absent from patents awarded in the United States (Davis & Glasgow, 2020). The innovative capabilities of nurses can help to improve patient care experiences, practices and outcomes, reduce health care costs and outcomes (Davis & Glasgow, 2020), and produce personal benefits and organizational operational performance (Moreira M R A et al, 2017).…”

Why Am I Bringing a Spatula to Class? An Innovation Relay!

“…Nurses have likely had a moment in their career when they think to themselves, “Nobody asked a nurse how to design this!” Nurses functioning in any professional role can have an impact on patient care, workflow, and efficiency through care innovation, product development, and new inventions. Nurses are responsible for innovative devices such as the Bili-Bonnet , used to hold eye protection in place for infants undergoing treatment for jaundice, and Colorsafe , an intravenous line color-coding system 1 . Unfortunately, few nurses have opportunities to create and contribute to patient care in this way.…”

“…Unfortunately, few nurses have opportunities to create and contribute to patient care in this way. An absence of nursing presence on patents and in groups that are developing new technologies and products is a missed opportunity for improving patient care experiences and patient outcomes, and perhaps reducing health care costs 1 . Introducing nursing students to the idea that nurses can and do function as inventors is essential to inspiring these future nurses to innovate.…”