Little is known about the behavior of hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) in primates because direct observations and competitive-repopulation assays are not feasible. Therefore, we used 2 different and independent experimental strategies, the tracking of transgene expression after retroviral-mediated gene transfer (N ؍ 11 baboons; N ؍ 7 rhesus macaques) and quantitation of the average telomere length of granulocytes (N ؍ 132 baboons; N ؍ 14 macaques), together with stochastic methods, to study HSC kinetics in vivo. The average replication rate for baboon HSCs is once per 36 weeks according to gene-marking analyses and once per 23 weeks according to telomere-shortening analyses. Comparable results were derived from the macaque data. These rates are substantially slower than the average replication rates previously reported for HSCs in mice (once per 2.5 weeks) and cats (once per 8.3 weeks). Because baboons and macaques live for 25 to 45 years, much longer than mice (ϳ2 years) and cats (12-18 years), we can compute that HSCs undergo a relatively constant number (ϳ80-200) of lifetime replications. Thus, our data suggest that the self-renewal capacity of mammalian stem cells in vivo is defined and evolutionarily conserved.
IntroductionHematopoiesis is the ordered process by which hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) proliferate and differentiate into mature blood cells. Through replication and differentiation, HSCs generate clones of progenitors, precursors, and mature cells, which support hematopoiesis throughout an animal's life. HSCs cannot be directly observed and are generally defined and identified by their function (their ability to reconstitute and maintain hematopoiesis).The most informative experimental approach for studying HSC kinetics is limiting-dilution competitive-repopulation experiments. Small numbers of cells with distinguishable phenotypes are transplanted into a recipient animal in which hematopoiesis has been ablated. After the HSCs engraft and restore blood cell production, the percentage of marrow progenitor cells or blood granulocytes of each phenotype is tracked over time, because this reflects the phenotype of contributing (differentiating) HSC clones. 1,2 Using such data, the frequency of HSCs in mice and cats was estimated, as were their average replication and differentiation rates. [3][4][5] Importantly, the estimated frequency of HSCs in mice derived with stochastic analyses was similar to frequencies estimated with independent methods. [6][7][8][9] In addition, the results from transplantation studies overlapped the results from studies of unperturbed hematopoiesis, including 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU)-labeling experiments. 6,9,10 Given the significant differences in estimates of the frequency of HSCs (number of HSCs/number of nucleated marrow cells; 4-8/10 5 vs. 6/10 7 ) and the average HSC-replication rate (once/2.5 weeks vs once/8-10 weeks) between mice and cats, we hypothesized that underlying biologic principles might explain these discrepancies. For example, our data and addit...