An individual-based model simulating goat response variability and long-term herd performance

Abstract

Finding ways of increasing the efficiency of production systems is a key issue of sustainability. System efficiency is based on long-term individual efficiency, which is highly variable and management driven. To study the effects of management on herd and individual efficiency, we developed the model simulation of goat herd management (SIGHMA). This dynamic model is individual-based and represents the interactions between technical operations (relative to replacement, reproduction and feeding) and individual biological processes (performance dynamics based on energy partitioning and production potential). It simulates outputs at both herd and goat levels over 20 years. A farmer's production project (i.e. a targeted milk production pattern) is represented by configuring the herd into female groups reflecting the organisation of kidding periods. Each group is managed by discrete events applying decision rules to simulate the carrying out of technical operations. The animal level is represented by a set of individual goat models. Each model simulates a goat's biological dynamics through its productive life. It integrates the variability of biological responses driven by genetic scaling parameters (milk production potential and mature body weight), by the regulations of energy partitioning among physiological functions and by responses to diet energy defined by the feeding strategy. A sensitivity analysis shows that herd efficiency was mainly affected by feeding management and to a lesser extent by the herd production potential. The same effects were observed on herd milk feed costs with an even lower difference between production potential and feeding management. SIGHMA was used in a virtual experiment to observe the effects of feeding strategies on herd and individual performances. We found that overfeeding led to a herd production increase and a feed cost decrease. However, this apparent increase in efficiency at the herd level (as feed cost decreased) was related to goats that had directed energy towards body reserves. Such a process is not efficient as far as feed conversion is concerned. The underfeeding strategy led to production decrease and to a slight feed cost decrease. This apparent increase in efficiency was related to goats that had mobilised their reserves to sustain production. Our results highlight the interest of using SIGHMA to study the underlying processes affecting herd performance and analyse the role of individual variability regarding herd response to management. It opens perspectives to further quantify the link between individual variability, herd performance and management and thus further our understanding of livestock farming systems.Keywords: simulation, herd, management, individual variability, dairy goat ImplicationsThe evaluation and design of sustainable livestock farming systems require predicting herd responses to management. This study describes a dairy goat herd model, representing dynamic interactions between management and individual biological processes. The model provides a...

Review: Make ruminants green again – how can sustainable intensification and agroecology converge for a better future?

“…The 'portfolio effect' states that communities with higher species richness are more likely to include the species that is best adapted to any given condition in fluctuating environments so that the number of species per se has a positive effect on system resilience (Dumont et al, 2017). Within herds, diversity of individual trade-offs between functions that was quantified in dairy goats (Puillet et al, 2010) and dairy cows (Ollion et al, 2016) does not increase herd milk production but is assumed to stabilise it under fluctuating environmental conditions. Abiotic and biotic interactions, including biogeochemical cycles and trophic interactions, lend ruminant systems further resilience properties (Dumont et al, 2017).…”

Initial insights on the performances and management of dairy cattle herds combining two breeds with contrasting features

“…Characterizing the three groups of MDH farmers' management strategies revealed that herd performances emerge from complex interactions between biological resources (particularly breed composition) and the decisional component (Puillet et al, 2010). Farmers in Group 1 seek a combination of animals or an animal (through cross-breeding) that provides a win-win situation between milk yields and low concentrate dependency.…”

Review: Towards the agroecological management of ruminants, pigs and poultry through the development of sustainable breeding programmes. II. Breeding strategies

“…Modelling studies accounting for a diversity of female functional profiles have provided some conceptual evidence that individual variability may help to maintain the production and ecological efficiency of ruminant farms (Tichit et al, 2011;Blanc et al, 2013). The diversity of individual tradeoffs between functions has been quantified in herds of dairy cows (Ollion et al, 2016), suckler cows (de la Torre et al, 2015) and dairy goats (Puillet et al, 2010). Such a diversity of trade-off profiles does not increase herd milk production but enables performance stability under fluctuating environmental conditions (Blanc et al, 2013), leading to more consistent economic margins for farmers.…”