An Information-Theoretic Framework for Optimal Design: Analysis of Protocols for Estimating Soft Tissue Parameters in Biaxial Experiments

Abstract

A new framework for optimal design based on the information-theoretic measures of mutual information, conditional mutual information and their combination is proposed. The framework is tested on the analysis of protocols—a combination of angles along which strain measurements can be acquired—in a biaxial experiment of soft tissues for the estimation of hyperelastic constitutive model parameters. The proposed framework considers the information gain about the parameters from the experiment as the key criterion to be maximised, which can be directly used for optimal design. Information gain is computed through k-nearest neighbour algorithms applied to the joint samples of the parameters and measurements produced by the forward and observation models. For biaxial experiments, the results show that low angles have a relatively low information content compared to high angles. The results also show that a smaller number of angles with suitably chosen combinations can result in higher information gains when compared to a larger number of angles which are poorly combined. Finally, it is shown that the proposed framework is consistent with classical approaches, particularly D-optimal design.

Quantifying the efficacy of voltage protocols in characterising ion channel kinetics: A novel information‐theoretic approach

“…In this sense, CMI X, Y ; Z ð Þ, quantifies the dependence/correlation between the parameters X and Y . For a more detailed discussion on the information-theoretic quantities presented above, the reader is referred to References 31,33,36,37. In an optimally designed experiment, it is desirable for there to be a strong correlation between the results of the experiment, and the underlying parameters the experimenter is trying to identify. This is equivalent to maximising the MI between the output of the model (which would be the measurement in an experiment) and the input parameters.…”

A physiologically realistic virtual patient database for the study of arterial haemodynamics

“…where the RHS terms can be computed from Equations ( 21), (25), and (27). In summary, the prior distributions for the 199 network parameters are specified in Section 5.2.…”

“…While not in the context of the subject area explored in this study, Bayesian techniques have been widely used in biomedical engineering for network modelling, 13 uncertainty quantification, 14,15 parameter estimation and inference, [16][17][18][19][20][21][22][23][24][25] optimisation, 26 and optimal design. 27 This article is organised as follows. First, a brief description of the physics-based pulse wave propagation model is presented.…”

“…The proposed framework may also be useful for the novel and active research area of in‐silico clinical trials, 12 for which generation of realistic virtual patients is a key consideration. While not in the context of the subject area explored in this study, Bayesian techniques have been widely used in biomedical engineering for network modelling, 13 uncertainty quantification, 14,15 parameter estimation and inference, 16–25 optimisation, 26 and optimal design 27 …”

Differential Models, Numerical Simulations and Applications

“…In [8] a new framework for optimal design was developed, by introducing new protocols for estimating soft tissue parameters in biaxial experiments. This framework is based on the information-theoretic measures of mutual information, and conditional mutual information and their combination is proposed.…”