Background Individually tailored contrast medium (CM) may improve vascular image quality in chest computed tomography (CT). Purpose To evaluate vascular attenuation in chest CT by comparing CM dose calculations using lean body mass (LBM) and body surface area (BSA) with a fixed-dose protocol. Material and Methods Patients referred for contrast-enhanced chest CT were categorized as either normal, muscular, or overweight. Patients were accordingly randomized into three CM dosing protocols: fixed-dose group (n = 87), LBM group (n = 92), and BSA group (n = 93). Results Of the patients, 94% in the fixed-dose group, 99% in the LBM group, and 98% in the BSA group achieved optimal vascular attenuation. In the overweight category, lower attenuation was demonstrated in the fixed-dose group compared to the LBM group ( P = 0.032) and the BSA group ( P = 0.010). In the fixed-dose group, vascular attenuation showed a negative correlation with total body weight for all body composition categories. In the LBM group, a positive correlation was observed between attenuation and total body weight in the muscular category ( P = 0.041), while a negative correlation was noted for the overweight category in the BSA group ( P = 0.049). Conclusion Fixed-dose CM protocol exhibited larger variations in vascular attenuation between patients of various body weights and body compositions compared to tailored CM doses based on LBM and BSA.