An investigation of causes of false positive single nucleotide polymorphisms using simulated reads from a small eukaryote genome

Abstract

BackgroundSingle Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNPs) are widely used molecular markers, and their use has increased massively since the inception of Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) technologies, which allow detection of large numbers of SNPs at low cost. However, both NGS data and their analysis are error-prone, which can lead to the generation of false positive (FP) SNPs. We explored the relationship between FP SNPs and seven factors involved in mapping-based variant calling — quality of the reference sequence, read length, choice of mapper and variant caller, mapping stringency and filtering of SNPs by read mapping quality and read depth. This resulted in 576 possible factor level combinations. We used error- and variant-free simulated reads to ensure that every SNP found was indeed a false positive.ResultsThe variation in the number of FP SNPs generated ranged from 0 to 36,621 for the 120 million base pairs (Mbp) genome. All of the experimental factors tested had statistically significant effects on the number of FP SNPs generated and there was a considerable amount of interaction between the different factors. Using a fragmented reference sequence led to a dramatic increase in the number of FP SNPs generated, as did relaxed read mapping and a lack of SNP filtering. The choice of reference assembler, mapper and variant caller also significantly affected the outcome. The effect of read length was more complex and suggests a possible interaction between mapping specificity and the potential for contributing more false positives as read length increases.ConclusionsThe choice of tools and parameters involved in variant calling can have a dramatic effect on the number of FP SNPs produced, with particularly poor combinations of software and/or parameter settings yielding tens of thousands in this experiment. Between-factor interactions make simple recommendations difficult for a SNP discovery pipeline but the quality of the reference sequence is clearly of paramount importance. Our findings are also a stark reminder that it can be unwise to use the relaxed mismatch settings provided as defaults by some read mappers when reads are being mapped to a relatively unfinished reference sequence from e.g. a non-model organism in its early stages of genomic exploration.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12859-015-0801-z) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Genome Wide Identification of Mutational Hotspots in the Apicomplexan Parasite Neospora caninum and the Implications for Virulence

“… Ribeiro et al. (2015) explored the relationship between the choice of tools and parameters, and their impact on false positive variants.…”

Genome‐wide variation in nucleotides and retrotransposons in alpine populations of Arabis alpina (Brassicaceae)

“…The consistent genetic structure (F IS and F ST ) inferred from both SNP sets appears remarkable provided that they differ by 33% of total SNPs comprised in TE sequences. The present data set suggests that current mapping software coupled with high-quality genome references may cope with a possible bias in the mapping in repetitive sequences (Ribeiro et al, 2015), even though marginal differences between the outcomes using all versus only non-TE SNPs remained in our study.…”

Reliable Detection of Herpes Simplex Virus Sequence Variation by High-Throughput Resequencing

“…The false positives in variant calling from the de novo assembly are largely due to mapping errors resulting from aligning to the consensus sequence rather than a complete genome. The reference quality is known to be critical along with stringent mapping, particularly with poorer, fragmented references [ 45 ]. While this paper focuses on high throughput short read sequences, there is new long read technology and observed improvements in reference quality due to combined assemblies from long and short reads [ 46 ].…”