An investigation of the impact of human capital and supply chain competitive drivers on firm performance in a developing country

Abstract

Purpose This paper aims to determine the effect that human capital and key competitive drivers such as quality, agility, and cost have on firm performance, whether this effect is related to the firm’s outsourcing strategy, and whether the firm size is relevant in explaining such relationships. Design This study uses structural equation modeling to test the hypothesized relationships for small to medium enterprises (SMEs) and large organizations using a custom survey based on a review of the literature and completed by 404 firms in the Valle del Cauca agro-industrial region in Colombia. Findings Human capital strategies are essential for the effective deployment of operational agility, quality, and cost management strategies, which impact firm performance through effective outsourcing strategies. These relationships, however, do not hold the same across firms of different sizes. Specifically, outsourcing practices are lacking amongst SMEs in the studied region. The study is limited to a specific region, with infrastructure and connectivity limitations that hinder or undermine otherwise potentially valuable third-party logistics strategies. Practical implications This paper contributes to the theory and practice in supply chain competitiveness by extending current knowledge of the impact of human capital and key competitive drivers on firm performance, highlighting regional specificities that could hinder firms’ competitiveness, and by presenting a novel, quantitative methodology seldom used for these topics.

Rethinking competency requirements in South African supply chain management

“…Therefore, further investigation is needed to verify this hypothesis and its implications for hiring practices, training and development initiatives in the SCM industry. These findings challenge the study ofSanta et al (2022), which posits that technical skills are the primary requirement in SCM job listings. Our methodology was designed to provide a comprehensive evaluation of SCM competencies beyond technical skills.…”

Size matters: The market–non-market strategy nexus and firm performance in South Africa

“…For example, Yao et al (2022) found that enterprise scale reduces the negative impact of financing constraints on firm performance, that is, smaller firms suffer more from restrictions on financing. Santa et al (2022) reported a positive relationship between cost and quality strategies and performance in large organisations but not for SMEs. Firm size, growth and performance are frequently correlated because large companies are more likely to have more resources, which enhances their ability to gather and analyse information and gives the company a competitive edge.…”

Determining Factors for Supply Chain Services Provider Selection and Long-Term Relationship Maintenance: Evidence from Greece

“…Businesses using a strategic outsourcing perspective seem to put greater emphasis on boosting flexibility, following cost elements, to the benefit of 3PL service providers' skill to adapt to shifts in demand, while placing a lesser emphasis on enhancing client service and the ability for breakthroughs [22]. Based on the findings of the same study, even though it is mentioned in the research as being one of the essential factors for choosing 3PL services, sustainability was not judged to be extremely relevant.…”