“…All these re¯ections illustrate a long and continuing academic debate on the relationship between science and technology. 24 Given the malleability of the concept, several people concluded that the de®nition was essentially social (Storer, 1964) or political (Cohen, 1948;Shepard, 1956;Daniels, 1967;Reagan, 1967;Falk, 1973;Layton, 1976;Toulmin, 1980;Gieryn, 1983;Kline, 1995), and at best needed to protect research from unrealizable expectations (Brooks, 1967). Some also argued that the de®nition rested on moral values.…”