You may order additional copies of this publication by sending your mailing information in label form through one of the following media. Please specify the publication title and number.
Abstract_ _________________________________________Native salmonid populations in the inland West are often restricted to small isolated habitats at risk from invasion by nonnative salmonids. However, further isolating these populations using barriers to prevent invasions can increase their extinction risk. This monograph reviews the state of knowledge about this tradeoff between invasion and isolation. We present a conceptual framework to guide analysis, focusing on four main questions concerning conservation value, vulnerability to invasion, persistence given isolation, and priorities when conserving multiple populations. Two examples illustrate use of the framework, and a final section discusses opportunities for making strategic decisions when faced with the invasion-isolation tradeoff.
Keywords
Executive_SummaryNative salmonid populations have declined throughout the world due to a host of human influences, including habitat degradation and loss, invasion of nonnative fishes, and overfishing. In many regions, suitable coldwater habitats for salmonids are found mainly in protected natural areas, so that these fishes are increasingly relegated to smaller and more isolated pieces of their former native ranges. Moreover, populations of native trout and charr in these relatively undisturbed habitats are often at further risk from invasion by nonnative salmonids from downstream. Faced with this dilemma, fisheries managers frequently consider using barriers to upstream movement to prevent invasion and displacement or hybridization. However, in doing so they face a tradeoff because isolating native salmonid populations in small headwater habitats may also increase their risk of extinction. Here we focus on native salmonids in the inland western U.S. (for example, cutthroat trout, Oncorhynchus clarkii; bull trout, Salvelinus confluentus), but this is an important problem for salmonids and other stream biota worldwide.This monograph reviews the state of knowledge about the factors that affect this tradeoff between invasion and isolation, and presents a framework for analyzing it and prioritizing conservation actions. Barriers to prevent invasions can pose problems for salmonids because these fish often need to move to complete their life history. Although anadromous salmonids are known for their extensive migrations, freshwater trout, charr, grayling, and whitefish also show remarkable flexibility in life history and diverse movement behaviors. Movements allow fish living in patchy environments to maximize fitness by placing each life history stage in habitats that provide optimum growth and survival. Likewise, in environments that fluctuate seasonally or among years, diverse life histories, and movements allow fish to avoid harsh conditions, or recolonize habitats after catastrophes.Isolation of fish populations using barriers can...