Analysis and correction of gradient nonlinearity bias in apparent diffusion coefficient measurements

Abstract

Purpose Gradient nonlinearity of MRI systems leads to spatially-dependent b-values and consequently high non-uniformity errors (10–20%) in ADC measurements over clinically relevant field-of-views. This work seeks practical correction procedure that effectively reduces observed ADC bias for media of arbitrary anisotropy in the fewest measurements. Methods All-inclusive bias analysis considers spatial and time-domain cross-terms for diffusion and imaging gradients. The proposed correction is based on rotation of the gradient nonlinearity tensor into the diffusion gradient frame where spatial bias of b-matrix can be approximated by its Euclidean norm. Correction efficiency of the proposed procedure is numerically evaluated for a range of model diffusion tensor anisotropies and orientations. Results Spatial dependence of nonlinearity correction terms accounts for the bulk (75–95%) of ADC bias for FA = 0.3–0.9. Residual ADC non-uniformity errors are amplified for anisotropic diffusion. This approximation obviates need for full diffusion tensor measurement and diagonalization to derive a corrected ADC. Practical scenarios are outlined for implementation of the correction on clinical MRI systems. Conclusions The proposed simplified correction algorithm appears sufficient to control ADC non-uniformity errors in clinical studies using three orthogonal diffusion measurements. The most efficient reduction of ADC bias for anisotropic medium is achieved with non-lab-based diffusion gradients.

How reliable are ADC measurements? A phantom and clinical study of cervical lymph nodes

“…Also, initiatives from the scientific community and technological improvements are expected to avoid sequences artifacts and systematic errors. Correction of non-linear gradient fields, one of the relevant issues, is the focus of ongoing research [37, 38]. …”

Pediatric Brain Tumor Consortium Multisite Assessment of Apparent Diffusion Coefficient z-Axis Variation Assessed with an Ice–Water Phantom

“…The main source of observed z-dependent ADC is believed to be gradient nonlinearity wherein the local gradient strength varies spatially, thereby creating a spatially-dependent bias in measurements. [10-12] If characterized for any given scanner, the coefficients of the quadratic polynomial could be used to make small z-dependent corrections to tumor ADC values, eliminating changes in tumor location along z as a source of error in longitudinal studies designed to gauge treatment response.…”

Quantitative Imaging in Radiation Oncology: An Emerging Science and Clinical Service

“…(Chenevert, Galban et al 2011) This same phantom was applied to characterize and correct for ADC bias from gradient nonlinearity affecting off-center measurements on clinical scanners, thereby reducing off-center ADC reproducibility towards bore-center values. (Malyarenko, Ross et al 2013) Broad scale incorporation of the ice-water phantom and gradient non-linearity correction appear likely to form a basis for standardization. (Newitt, Tan et al 2015) Refinements to the methods for specific clinical sites have also been achieved.…”