Analysis of accessibility to emergency rooms by dynamic population from mobile phone data: Geography of social inequity in South Korea

Abstract

Accessibility of emergency medical care is one of the crucial factors in evaluating national primary medical care systems. While many studies have focused on this issue, there was a fundamental limit to the measurement of accessibility of emergency rooms, because the commonly used census-based population data are difficult to provide realistic information in terms of time and space. In this study, we evaluated the geographical accessibility of emergency rooms in South Korea by using dynamic population counts from mobile phone data. Such population counts were more accurate and up-to-date because they are obtained by aggregating the number of mobile phone users in a 50-by-50 m grid of a locational field, weighted by stay time. Considering both supply and demand of emergency rooms, the 2step floating catchment analysis was implemented. As a result, urban areas, including the capital city Seoul, showed lower accessibility to emergency rooms, whereas rural areas recorded higher accessibility. This result was contrary to the results analyzed by us based on census-based population data: higher accessibility in urban areas and lower in rural. This implies that using solely census data for accessibility analysis could lead to certain errors, and adopting mobile-based population data would represent the real-world situations for solving problems of social inequity in primary medical care. OPEN ACCESS Citation: Yun SB, Kim S, Ju S, Noh J, Kim C, Wong MS, et al. (2020) Analysis of accessibility to emergency rooms by dynamic population from mobile phone data: Geography of social inequity in South Korea. PLoS ONE 15(4): e0231079. https://

Mapping the Accessibility of Medical Facilities of Wuhan during the COVID-19 Pandemic

“…Recently, a noticeable trend is that more types of data, such as data based on location-based service (LBS), have been combined with accessibility analysis to correlate actual population flow and distance decay effect, etc. [26,32] Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, spatial accessibility assessments of COVID-19 patients to healthcare facilities were studied by researchers [33][34][35]. In these studies, it was believed that people living in areas of dense population or on the margins were disproportionately disadvantaged in terms of the access to medical facilities and healthcare [36,37].…”

Analysis of characteristics and trends of the In-Hospital Cardiac Arrest incidence in the Republic of Korea: clinical usefulness of national health insurance claim data

“…Based on data of the AHA's GWTG-R, Merchant et al reported no statistically significant difference between incidence of IHCA in urban and rural areas [25]. This difference is due to the medical accessibility resulting from the geographical factors and relatively unforced health care delivery system in the nation [26].…”

Impacts of COVID-19 on bike-sharing usages in Seoul, South Korea

“…Several studies have pointed out that although census-based population data is the most meaningful representation of the social and economic status of people, it is hard to reflect dynamic spatial-temporal patterns of people from this data alone. Specifically, the census-based population represents the number of people who are registered in a given district, and it is difficult to capture the human dynamics that can be reflected by mobile-based population patterns ( Baker et al, 2017 ; Yun et al, 2020 ). Also, static census-based populations are collected every 5 to 10 years, whereas mobile-based population information captures real-time information.…”

“…Also, static census-based populations are collected every 5 to 10 years, whereas mobile-based population information captures real-time information. Mobile phone-based population data was considered to analyze actual demands for public facilities, and the human dynamics of the spatial-temporal characteristics of people ( Jung & Nam, 2019 ; Jo et al, 2020 ; Yun et al, 2020 ). Gender information from mobile-based floating population data was used to analyze gender equality with regard to the use of urban space in Seoul ( Jo et al, 2020 ).…”

“…Gender information from mobile-based floating population data was used to analyze gender equality with regard to the use of urban space in Seoul ( Jo et al, 2020 ). Yun et al (2020) explained that using mobile phone-based data allowed researchers to consider both active and inactive real-time floating population for analysis. They argued that using only census data for accessibility analysis had limitations and could lead to certain errors.…”