Analysis of Clinicians’ Perceptual Cough Evaluation

Abstract

This study examined the relationships between subjective descriptors and objective airflow measures of cough. We hypothesized that coughs with specific airflow characteristics would share common subjective perceptual descriptions. Thirty clinicians (speech-language pathologists, otolaryngologists, and neurologists) perceptually evaluated ten cough audio samples with specific airflow characteristics determined by peak expiratory flow rate, cough expired volume, cough duration, and number of coughs in the cough epoch. Participants rated coughs by strength, duration, quality, quantity, and overall potential effectiveness for airway protection. Perception of cough strength and effectiveness was determined by the combination of presence of pre-expulsive compression phase, short peak expiratory airflow rate rise time, high peak expiratory flow rates, and high cough volume acceleration. Perception of cough abnormality was defined predominantly by descriptors of breathiness and strain. Breathiness was characteristic for coughs with either absent compression phases and relatively high expiratory airflow rates or coughs with significantly low expired volumes and reduced peak flow rates. In contrast, excessive strain was associated with prolonged compression phases and low expiratory airflow rates or the absence of compression phase with high peak expiratory rates. The study participants reached greatest agreement in distinguishing between single and multiple coughs. Their assessment of cough strength and effectiveness was less consistent. Finally, the least agreement was shown in determining the quality categories. Modifications of cough airflow can influence perceptual cough evaluation outcomes. However, the inconsistency of cough ratings among our participants suggests that a uniform cough rating system is required.

Effect of Brain Lesions on Voluntary Cough in Patients with Supratentorial Stroke: An Observational Study

“…In order to further delineate the exact correlation between PCF and PAS, future VLSM studies that include those with no cough disturbance are warranted. Subjective judgment of cough strength can be misleading [ 47 , 48 ], and prospective studies with large sample sizes that include those with no cough weakness are warranted. Nevertheless, patients with a lower PCF showed an increased incidence of respiratory complications, which was consistent with the results of multiple regression analysis reported by Sohn et al [ 28 ].…”

Assessment of cough in head and neck cancer patients at risk for dysphagia—An overview

“…54 Unlike coughing that requires complete glottal closure, throat clearing is another reflexive or voluntary maneuver that removes laryngeal residue or mucus, but which involves partial vocal fold adduction. 43 Like the expiratory reflex, throat clearing does not have an inspiratory phase. 49…”

“…84 However, some cough sound features, which have been reliably reported via automatic cough sound analysis, relate inconsistently to perceptual ratings. 43,86 Laciuga et al have reported perceptual difficulties in differentiating a cough event from a throat clearing, but also from perceptually differentiating a single cough from a cough epoch. 43 Cough duration may also be auditorily misjudged.…”

To Cough or Not to Cough? Examining the Potential Utility of Cough Testing in the Clinical Evaluation of Swallowing

“…Laciuga and colleagues recently investigated relationships between perceptual ratings of cough and objective airflow measures of cough [60]. Thirty clinicians (speech-language pathologists, otolaryngologists, and neurologists) rated the subjective parameters of strength, duration, quality, quantity, and overall ‘effectiveness’ of ten audio recordings of cough containing specific airflow characteristics.…”