“…Therefore, a thinner absorber can be used in UTC-PD for a larger transit-time-limited bandwidth without sacrificing the RC-limited bandwidth by welldesigning a relatively thick collector. Additionally, some references show the detailed theoretical and experimental analysis of the characteristics for PIN-PD and UTC-PD, including energy band, electrical field, doping mechanism, optimization of absorber and collector, bandwidth, responsivity, saturation, and output power [56][57][58][59][60][61][62] as well as transient response [63], dark current [64,65], and P-contact shapes [66]. According to the abovementioned bandwidth equations and the values from Table 1, the 3-dB bandwidths for PIN-PD and UTC-PD can be calculated as shown in Figure 5a, including the assumed values during the calculation.…”