IntroductionDiverse anti-cancer strategies are emerging. 1-25 These approaches are not mutually exclusive and will eventually complement each other. Alex Varshavsky has described how to design a molecular device, with potentially unlimited precision and selectivity. 1 It will recognize homozygous deletions (HDs) specific for cancer and restrict cytotoxicity to cancer cells.In contrast, the cytotoxicity of current small molecular drugs is not restricted to cancer cells. But what about drug combinations? In analogy, it is impossible to write Hamlet by using only one letter, but using a combination of letters, Shakespeare wrote Hamlet. Of course these combinations should not be scrambled. Currently, drugs are combined for synergy, to broaden the activity and to target all the variety of sub-clones in heterogenic cancer. Here we will discuss a completely different class of combinations: namely, restrictive combinations (RCs), designed to narrow the variety of targeted cells and to restrict cytotoxicity to those particular cells. Intriguingly, RCs and the Varshavsky device are based on similar principles. What are they?
Varshavsky's DemonLet us consider, a DNA-vector 1 (or circuit or something that I will poetically call Demon for generalization and brevity). With a toxic payload (or a killer) and a sleeping guard in her pockets, Demon enters the cell, checking for DNA for the sequences that are absent in cancer cells. Once the sequences are found, the guard awakens and cuts Demon into peaces, disabling the payload. In cancer cells the DNA sequences are not found, the guard remains asleep and the toxic payload kills the cell.There are two points to emphasize. First, demon does not actually recognize cancer. It recognizes cellular context that in this case is highly specific for normal cells. Second, it employs a guard, who protects normal cells. In the Varshavsky scenario, both a guard and a killer are parts of the same vector. But generally speaking both activities could be independent.
Demon Consisting of Two Small MoleculesThe first molecule checks cellular context. For example, it checks for the absence of functional wild type p53. How could that be done? To probe for p53 status, the first molecule (for example doxorubicin, DOX) damages DNA. DOX must be used at low doses (low-DOX) so it causes just a few random damages that are not lethal. 26,27 This is a test. In cells with p53, this test induces p53, which causes G1/G2 arrest. This arrest is the "guard" against the cytotoxicity of the second drug. Arriving independently, the second drug Taxol is a 'killer'. But Taxol kills cells only during mitosis. Then only cells with mutant p53 will be killed by Taxol. The cytotoxicity of low-Dox/Taxol is restricted to the cells with absent functional p53.The analogy with Varshavsky's Demon can be extended. There must be the lag time between the device entry and its cytotoxic action. 1 Otherwise normal cells will not be protected by a sleeping guard. After the lag time, a patient should receive an inducer that activates payl...