“…In step three, based on the KEQs, the data from selected case studies was collected and categorized by (1) transit system characteristics, (2) features of insulators, (3) insulator failure causes, (4) insulator failure costs, and (5) insulator failure mitigating practices. Subject matter experts (SMEs) from eight active transit agencies with third-rail systems were asked to Salt fog/air Schneider et al [36], Vohra [9] Snow and ice accumulation Vohra [9] Defective product/material Nyamupangedengu et al [22] Corrosion and fitting Venkatesulu [28], Luder et al [5] Damage from impact Jiang et al [24], Vohra [30] System voltage fluctuation Reddy [8], Vohra [9] Mechanical stress Nyamupangedengu et al [22] Flashover/arcing Verma and Reddy [6], Sun et al [14], Schneider et al [36], Chakraborty [37], Slama et al [19], Douar et al [20] Cracking/fracture Luder et al [5], Vohra [9] Dirt build-up Sun et al [14], Slama et al [19], Douar et al [20], Sima et al [21], Cavallin et al [23] Urban Rail Transit provide additional information for the data collection. Finally, the data was statistically and descriptively analyzed and compared through synthesis of similarities and differences.…”