Analysis of healthcare service utilization after transport-related injuries by a mixture of hidden Markov models

Abstract

BackgroundTransport injuries commonly result in significant disease burden, leading to physical disability, mental health deterioration and reduced quality of life. Analyzing the patterns of healthcare service utilization after transport injuries can provide an insight into the health of the affected parties, allow improved health system resource planning, and provide a baseline against which any future system-level interventions can be evaluated. Therefore, this research aims to use time series of service utilization provided by a compensation agency to identify groups of claimants with similar utilization patterns, describe such patterns, and characterize the groups in terms of demographic, accident type and injury type.MethodsTo achieve this aim, we have proposed an analytical framework that utilizes latent variables to describe the utilization patterns over time and group the claimants into clusters based on their service utilization time series. To perform the clustering without dismissing the temporal dimension of the time series, we have used a well-established statistical approach known as the mixture of hidden Markov models (MHMM). Ensuing the clustering, we have applied multinomial logistic regression to provide a description of the clusters against demographic, injury and accident covariates.ResultsWe have tested our model with data on psychology service utilization from one of the main compensation agencies for transport accidents in Australia, and found that three clear clusters of service utilization can be evinced from the data. These three clusters correspond to claimants who have tended to use the services 1) only briefly after the accident; 2) for an intermediate period of time and in moderate amounts; and 3) for a sustained period of time, and intensely. The size of these clusters is approximately 67%, 27% and 6% of the number of claimants, respectively. The multinomial logistic regression analysis has showed that claimants who were 30 to 60-year-old at the time of accident, were witnesses, and who suffered a soft tissue injury were more likely to be part of the intermediate cluster than the majority cluster. Conversely, claimants who suffered more severe injuries such as a brain head injury or anon-limb fracture injury and who started their service utilization later were more likely to be part of the sustained cluster.ConclusionThis research has showed that clustering of service utilization time series is an effective approach for identifying the main user groups and utilization patterns of a healthcare service. In addition, using logistic regression to describe the clusters in terms of demographic, injury and accident covariates has helped identify the salient attributes of the claimants in each cluster. This finding is very important for the compensation agency and potentially other authorities as it provides a baseline to improve need understanding, resource planning and service provision.

Machine learning applications to clinical decision support in neurosurgery: an artificial intelligence augmented systematic review

“…Once an appropriate algorithm has been selected, a predictive model is developed through appropriate training, calibration, validation, and peer review. The performance of supervised ML models is typically evaluated by statistical outputs, including accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV), and the area under the receiver operating characteristics curve (AUC), among others [36,49,76]. These statistics allow the comparison of the performance of different forms of supervised learning models and allow the researcher to determine the applicability of the model to clinical practice [36,98].…”

Investigating Risk Factors and Predicting Complications in Deep Brain Stimulation Surgery with Machine Learning Algorithms

“…The development of algorithms that incorporate gradient boosting has produced highly robust regression and classification methods 36 . XGBMs appear to have performed well in various domains 35,[37][38][39][40][41] and have been shown to perform particularly well on datasets characterized by class imbalance 42,43 . Many supervised learning algorithms perform well as predictive tools partly because they can estimate complex nonlinear relationships in high volume datasets using weighted statistical functions in a way that cannot be perceived by linear models or clinicians [44][45][46][47] .…”

Health-related Quality of Life Among Adult Patients With Cancer in Uganda

“…Data were analysed using Stata statistical software version 15 [20]. Descriptive data analyses are presented as means, standard deviations, frequencies, and percentages.…”