Analysis of Judicial Precedents Cases Regarding Skin Cancer from 1997 to 2017 in Republic of Korea

Abstract

Background Both medical disputes and the incidence of skin cancer are increasing in Korea. Objective The aim of this study was to figure out the medical litigation related to skin cancer and propose a method to prevent the medical disputes. Methods Skin cancer-related judgments were searched by The Supreme Court of Korea's Written Judgment Management System based on the keywords for skin cancer. The search system included sentenced cases at the Lower Courts, the Appellate Courts, and the Supreme Court from 1997 to 2017. Results Seven cases were selected as the litigation cases related to skin cancer. Four cases (57.1%) presented malignant melanoma, while the rest presented squamous cell carcinoma, metastatic skin cancer, and peripheral T cell lymphoma (1 case in each). Four cases resulted in death from cancer metastasis, and 3 cases presented as sequelae. The legal issues related to the medical disputes could be categorized as follows: misdiagnosis, delayed diagnosis, performance error, and lack of informed consent. Delayed diagnosis and lack of informed consent were the most common issues (n=4) in the precedents. Five cases (71.4%) were sentenced the awarded amounts to the plaintiff, including 2 cases of settlement decision. The average awarded amount was 42,553,644±27,567,455 Korean won. Conclusion Physicians should pay attention to the cases of the skin cancer to prevent medical malpractice and disputes. The practices pertaining to proper diagnosis, treatment plans, and obtaining an informed consent should be followed during the course of treating skin cancer.

Analysis of acne‐related judicial precedents from 1997 to 2018 in South Korea

“…Acne-related judgments were searched using the search engine Supreme Court of Korea's Written Judgment Management System. 6 This system includes sentences on civil proceedings in South Korea. The search terms were "medical malpractice" and "acne" in the time period 1997-2018.…”

“…Acne‐related judgments were searched using the search engine Supreme Court of Korea’s Written Judgment Management System . This system includes sentences on civil proceedings in South Korea.…”

“…Dermatologists are also not free from such problems. [3][4][5][6][7][8] Read et al 3 reported malpractice cases in the treatment of a variety of dermatological medical conditions, and acne was the most common skin disease with the exception of malignant skin neoplasm. In addition, acne was the second most frequent indication for malpractice litigation regarding laser procedures in the head and neck.…”

“…It is important for physicians to prevent medical malpractice and subsequent legal disputes. Dermatologists are also not free from such problems . Read et al .…”