A suitable aluminum additive in cast iron makes it resistant to heat in a variety of environments and increases the abrasion resistance of the cast iron. It should be noted that high-aluminum cast iron has the potential to become an important eco-material. The basic elements from which it is made—iron, aluminum and a small amount of carbon—are inexpensive components. This material can be made from contaminated aluminum scrap, which is increasingly found in metallurgical scrap. The idea is to produce iron castings with the highest possible proportion of aluminum. Such castings are heat-resistant and have good abrasive properties. The only problem to be solved is to prevent the activation of the phenomenon of spontaneous decomposition. This phenomenon is related to the Al4C3 hygroscopic aluminum carbide present in the structure of cast iron. Previous attempts to determine the causes of spontaneous disintegration by various researchers do not describe them comprehensively. In this article, the mechanism of the spontaneous disintegration of high-aluminum cast iron castings is defined. The main factor is the large relative geometric dimensions of Al4C3 carbide. In addition, methods for counteracting the phenomenon of spontaneous decay are developed, which is the main goal of the research. It is found that a reduction in the size of the Al4C3 carbide or its removal lead to the disappearance of the self-disintegration effect of high-aluminum cast iron. For this purpose, an increased cooling rate of the casting is used, as well as the addition of elements (Ti, B and Bi) to cast iron, supported in some cases by heat treatment. The tests are conducted on the cast iron with the addition of 34–36% mass aluminum. The molten metal is superheated to 1540 °C and then the cast iron samples are cast at 1420 °C. A molding sand with bentonite is used to produce casting molds.