Anatomy of an Ethical Dilemma: The Practice

An Ethical Dilemma: The Dishonest Doctor

“…For example, society is benefitted by having a credible, honest medical community whom people can trust. Aroskar (1980) explained utilitarianism as focusing on societal "consequences of actions, on the greatest amount of happiness or the least amount of harm for the greatest number" (p. 659).…”

“…Loeb also says that '?tonoring ethical obligations ensures good," although some actions may be difficult and have painful consequences (p. 281). Aroskar (1980) says that deontology "considers the nature of an act itself" (p. 659). According to Kant's categorical imperative or principle of universalizability, one should act only on a maxim that can be applied in any similar situation (Aroskar, 1980).…”

“…Aroskar (1980) says that deontology "considers the nature of an act itself" (p. 659). According to Kant's categorical imperative or principle of universalizability, one should act only on a maxim that can be applied in any similar situation (Aroskar, 1980). One example is to tell the truth always.…”

“…This has been called the golden rule principle: Treat others as one would want to be treated. Kant also believed that people should be treated as ends, not simply as means (Aroskar, 1980;Beauchamp & Childress, 1989). Kant's philosophy could have been applied to this case.…”

“…Despite any progress on the issue of veracity, High believed that doctors still failed to collaborate and share decision making with clients. Aroskar (1980) stated that "in the hospital setting, the physician is in the position of power and authority: but one cannot automatically conclude that the physician "is the best person to decide what is in the patient's best interest" (p. 661).…”