Animals as Sentinels of Human Environmental Health Hazards: An Evidence-Based Analysis

Abstract

Despite recognition that animals could be serving as ''sentinels'' for environmental risks to human health, there are no evidence-based guidelines for the use of animal sentinel data in human health decision making. We performed a systematic review of the animal sentinel literature to assess the evidence linking such events to human health. A search of MEDLINE identified peer-reviewed original studies of animals as sentinels for either chemical or biological environmental hazards. A limited search of the CAB and AG-RICOLA databases was also performed. We classified a random sample of 100 studies from the MED-LINE search according to species, hazard, and health outcome examined; study methods; and linkages to human health. Animal sentinel studies were difficult to locate in MEDLINE because of a lack of adequate key words for this concept. We found significant limitations in the study methods used to investigate animal sentinel events. Clear linkages to human health were frequently absent. Studies of sentinel events in animal populations hold potential for the recognition and control of human environmental health hazards, yet a number of barriers exist to using such data for evidence-based human health decisions. There is a need for greater data sharing and cooperative research between human and animal health professionals regarding environmental hazards and health outcomes in animal and human populations.

Reservoir host competence and the role of domestic and commensal hosts in the transmission of Trypanosoma cruzi

“…A thorough interpretation of surveillance data for risk assessment requires consideration of the linkages between animal sentinel events and human health (Rabinowitz et al, 2005). The distribution of T. cruzi seropositivity in shelter dogs (8.8%) across Texas (USA) was taken as a spatial index of Chagas disease risk (Tenney et al, 2014).…”

A naturally occurring cancer with molecular connectivity to human diseases

“…These naturally occurring molluscan diseases might also be developed as models where exposure pathways or molecular mechanisms are shared with human diseases. 29 …”

Modeling of Wildlife-Associated Zoonoses: Applications and Caveats

“…With this in mind, wildlife health is of interest not only in terms of conservation and wildlife management objectives, but also for public health. Because of this, animals in general and wildlife in particular are being identified as important sentinels for the surveillance of emerging infectious diseases that can threaten human health (Rabinowitz et al 2005;Halliday et al 2007). There is an increasing need to identify the coupling points at the human-wildlife interface where zoonotic disease transmission occurs and public and animal health can be threatened.…”