Motivated by the need for sustainable, bio-based materials, the living anionic polymerization of the under-explored terpene monomer β-ocimene (Oc) was investigated for the first time. Homopolymers with M n up to 50 kg mol −1 of the Oc isomeric mixture (E:Z = trans:cis = 70:30) were synthesized in cyclohexane and analyzed with respect to molecular weight control, dispersity, microstructure, and glass transition temperature, T g . Employing styrene as a comonomer, diblock copolymers, and a series of statistical copolymers with M n up to 20 kg mol −1 with varying comonomer compositions offered the opportunity to tailor the glass transition of the copolymers. Real-time 1 H nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) kinetics indicated a remarkably divergent reactivity of the trans and cis isomers. This unveiled the unique observation that the homopolymerization of Oc is in fact a copolymerization of the cis and trans isomers, which one might name as "stereo-copolymerization" (r trans = 3.16; r cis = 0.32). Kinetic studies of the statistical copolymerization of the Oc isomeric mixture with styrene revealed an astonishingly contradictory reactivity of the two isomers (r trans < r cis ). The reactivity differences of the cis and trans isomers in the polymerization were utilized to isolate the individual isomers for the first time. Subsequently, they were independently homo-and copolymerized with styrene. The complex mechanism of these polymerizations and the rather high polymer dispersities (Đ ≈ 1.6−2) are discussed using various kinetic models supported by density functional theory modeling. The surprisingly different behavior of the two isomers with styrene was validated experimentally via a 1 H NMR-monitored chemical titration.