“…Calculation results by Chaves et al showed that, although larger than the usual trion binding energy in TMDCs, even the trion binding energy in suspended monolayer BP is only ∼51 meV, and decreases to ∼34 meV in supported BP, which is much smaller than the claim by Yang et al [138] . Due to the discrepancy, the validity [41,42,125,126] 8.2(x), 2.3(y) [133] AC(x) Multi-interband w 0.3-0.45 [102,106,108] , 0.9 [104] Bulk / MX (M = Ge, Sn; X = S, Se) GeS 1L w/o ∼0.7-1.2 [34,128,129] 6.7(x), 4.5(y) [34] AC(x) Multi-valley exciton w ∼0.6 [129] Bulk / <0.1 GeSe 1L w/o ∼0.3-0.4 [34,130,129] 21.2(x), 15.4(y) [34] w ∼0.2 [129] Bulk / <0.1 SnS 1L w/o ∼0.5-0.9 [34,128] 15.1(x), 15.1(y) [34] Bulk / <0.1 SnSe 1L w/o ∼0.3 [34,130] 27.3(x), 25(y) [34] Bulk / <0.1…”