Only a few monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) have been isolated that recognize conserved sites in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Env proteins and possess broad neutralizing activities. Other MAbs directed against targets in various domains of Env have been described that are strongly neutralizing, but they possess limited breadth. One such MAb, 2909, possesses a uniquely potent neutralizing activity specific for a quaternary epitope on SF162 Env that requires the presence of both the V2 and the V3 domains. We now show that replacement of the SF162 V3 sequence with consensus V3 sequences of multiple subtypes led to attenuated but still potent neutralization by 2909 and that the main determinants for the type specificity of 2909 reside in the V2 domain. A substitution at position 160 completely eliminated 2909 reactivity, and mutations at position 167 either attenuated or potentiated neutralization by this antibody. Different substitutions at the same positions in V2 were previously shown to introduce epitopes recognized by MAbs 10/76b and C108g and to allow potent neutralization by these MAbs. Two substitutions at key positions in the V2 domain of JR-FL Env also allowed potent expression of the 2909 epitope, and single substitutions in YU2 V2 were sufficient for expression of the 2909, C108g, and 10/76b epitopes. These results demonstrate that the minimal epitopes for 2909, C108g, and 10/76b differed from that of the clade B consensus sequence only at single positions and suggest that all three MAbs recognize distinct variants of a relatively conserved sequence in V2 that is a particularly sensitive mediator of HIV-1 neutralization.A major factor thwarting the development of a successful human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) vaccine is the resistance of primary isolates to neutralization by classes of antibodies commonly induced after infection or immunization (1, 45). Sequence variability at major neutralization sites contributes to this effect, but recent evidence argues that the major factor in this resistance is conformational shielding of susceptible epitopes in the native oligomeric complex (18,28). Nlinked glycans located in various regions of Env play a general role in epitope masking (6,7,22,39), and increasing evidence documents a dominant role for the V1/V2 domain in such masking (6,12,18,28,34,44). One approach being investigated to overcome the effects of this masking is to delete the V2 domain from Env-based immunogens. Oligomeric V2-deleted forms of gp140 have been reported to possess enhanced immunogenicity over the wild-type molecule and to produce increased titers of neutralizing antibodies (8,21,33,43). However, these effects are only modest, and recent studies indicate that this approach involves the induction of type-specific neutralizing antibodies directed mostly toward highly variable epitopes in V1 that possess limited neutralizing activities for heterologous isolates (10, 42).The critical role of conformational masking in neutralization resistance poses a major conundrum fo...