Nisin and related lantibiotics kill bacteria by pore formation or by sequestering lipid II. Some lantibiotics sequester lipid II into clusters, which were suggested to kill cells through delocalized peptidoglycan synthesis. Here, we show that cluster formation is always concomitant with (i) membrane pore formation and (ii) membrane depolarization. Nisin variants that cluster lipid II kill L-form bacteria with similar efficiency, suggesting that delocalization of peptidoglycan synthesis is not the primary killing mechanism of these lantibiotics.
Lantibiotics form a class of antimicrobial peptides that contain thioether rings formed by lanthionine residues. Nisin, the most studied lantibiotic, is a 34-residue peptide produced by Lactococcus species with antimicrobial activity against a wide range of Grampositive bacteria (see Fig. S1 in the supplemental material). Nisin targets lipid II, the precursor molecule for peptidoglycan (PG) synthesis (1), and kills via two modes of action: (i) formation of large membrane pores and (ii) interference with PG synthesis.Two lanthionine rings in nisin (A and B) form a pyrophosphatebinding cage that binds lipid II and is highly conserved among lipid II-binding lantibiotics (2). The C terminus of nisin is important for membrane integration (3, 4). Nisin-lipid II complexes (8:4 stoichiometry) form pores in the membrane (5-7) that result in the efflux of small molecules and influx of sodium ions, which will lead to cell death. Mutations in the hinge region of nisin either block or severely inhibit pore formation activity, presumably by preventing the hinge region (residues N20, M21, and K22) (see Fig. S1 in the supplemental material) from flipping the C-terminal tail into and across the membrane. Mutants PP-nisin (N20P M21P) and ⌬⌬-nisin (⌬N20 ⌬M21) fail to form pores in liposome efflux assays (7,8). Nisin 1-22 (⌬23-34) cannot dissipate the membrane potential of sensitive Lactococcus species (9). Similar to nisin 1-22, mutacin 1140 and mersacidin bind lipid II but are too short to span the membrane (6, 10). Mutants that do not efficiently form pores are thought to act by affecting cell wall synthesis only.Two mechanisms for lantibiotic interference with PG synthesis are proposed: "occlusion" and "clustering." Occlusion is the binding to the pyrophosphate moiety of lipid II, which blocks incorporation of lipid II into glycan strands (11). Clustering is the formation of nonphysiological domains containing lipid II and nisin in the membrane, which results in delocalized PG synthesis (12).Recently, we used PP-nisin as a tool to cluster lipid II into domains to determine the effect of delocalized lipid II on the localization of proteins involved in PG synthesis (13). PP-nisin was expected not to affect the membrane potential of live cells (7); however, we found that PP-nisin induced membrane potential loss (13). This compromised the localization of many membraneassociated proteins, including MreB (14). Here, we further investigated the effects of various nisin mutants on lipid II clust...