Immunization with recombinant proteins may provide a safer alternative to live vaccinia virus for prophylaxis of poxvirus infections. Although antibody protects against vaccinia virus infection, the mechanism is not understood and the selection of immunogens is daunting as there are dozens of surface proteins and two infectious forms known as the mature virion (MV) and the enveloped virion (EV). Our previous studies showed that mice immunized with soluble forms of EV membrane proteins A33 and B5 and MV membrane protein L1 or passively immunized with antibodies to these proteins survived an intranasal challenge with vaccinia virus. The present study compared MV protein A27, which has a role in virus attachment to glycosaminoglycans on the cell surface, to L1 with respect to immunogenicity and protection. Although mice developed similar levels of neutralizing antibody after immunizations with A27 or L1, A27-immunized mice exhibited more severe disease upon an intranasal challenge with vaccinia virus. In addition, mice immunized with A27 and A33 were not as well protected as mice receiving L1 and A33. Polyclonal rabbit anti-A27 and anti-L1 IgG had equivalent MV-neutralizing activities when measured by the prevention of infection of human or mouse cells or cells deficient in glycosaminoglycans or by adding antibody prior to or after virus adsorption. Nevertheless, the passive administration of antibody to A27 was poorly protective compared to the antibody to L1. These studies raise questions regarding the basis for antibody protection against poxvirus disease and highlight the importance of animal models for the early evaluation of vaccine candidates.Smallpox was eradicated following widespread vaccination with live vaccinia virus (VACV) (21). However, most people born within the last three decades have not been vaccinated and consequently are susceptible to smallpox. Because serious side effects are associated with the smallpox vaccine (12), individuals or their close contacts who are immunocompromised or have a history of dermatitis or heart disease might be excluded from future vaccination should the need arise. Attenuated and nonreplicating strains of VACV are being clinically tested as alternative smallpox vaccines (33,50,68), but in some cases, high doses are required to achieve good immune responses and the possibility of adverse effects has not been entirely excluded. Additional genetically engineered strains of VACV (14, 62, 67) and recombinant DNA or viral proteins (referenced below) are still in preclinical testing.Protection against secondary orthopoxvirus infections is largely antibody mediated (48). However, because poxviruses are large and complex, the selection of the best immunogens is a difficult task. Two major infectious forms of VACV exist: the mature virus (MV) consists of a nucleoprotein core surrounded by a lipoprotein membrane, whereas the enveloped virus (EV) is essentially an MV enclosed by a second viral membrane (45). The intracellular wrapping of MVs facilitates cytoplasmic transport, e...