␣ 1 -Antichymotrypsin is a member of the serine proteinase inhibitor, or serpin, family that typically forms very long-lived, enzymatically inactive 1:1 complexes (denoted E*I*) with its target proteinases. Serpins share a conserved tertiary structure, in which an exposed region of amino acid residues (called the reactive center loop or RCL) acts as bait for a target proteinase. Within E*I*, the two proteins are linked covalently as a result of nucleophilic attack by Ser 195 of the serine proteinase on the P1 residue within the RCL of the serpin. This species is formally similar to the acyl enzyme species normally seen as an intermediate in serpin proteinase catalysis. However, its subsequent hydrolysis is extremely slow as a result of structural changes within the enzyme leading to distortion of the active site. There is at present an ongoing debate concerning the structure of the E*I* complex; in particular, as to whether the enzyme, bound to P1, maintains its original position at the top of the serpin molecule or instead translocates across the entire length of the serpin, with concomitant insertion of RCL residues P1-P14 within -sheet A and a large separation of the enzyme and RCL residue P1. We report time-resolved fluorescence energy transfer and rapid mixing/quench studies that support the former model. Our results indicate that the distance between residue P1 in ␣ 1 -antichymotrypsin and the amino terminus of chymotrypsin actually decreases on conversion of the encounter complex E⅐I to E*I*. These results led us to formulate a comprehensive mechanism that accounted both for our results and for those of others supporting the two different E*I* structures. In this mechanism, partial insertion of the RCL, with no large perturbation of the P1 enzyme distance, is followed by covalent acyl enzyme formation. Full insertion can subsequently take place, in a reversible fashion, with the position of equilibrium between the partially and fully inserted complexes depending on the particular serpin-proteinase pair under consideration.1 is a member of the serine proteinase inhibitor, or serpin, family that typically forms very long-lived, enzymatically inactive 1:1 complexes (denoted E*I*) with its target proteinases. Serpins share a conserved tertiary structure in which an exposed region of amino acid residues (called the reactive center loop or RCL) acts as bait for a target proteinase. For ACT, this loop extends from residues 342 to 367, denoted P17-P9Ј, in which, following the nomenclature of Schechter and Berger (1), the scissile bond cleaved by the targeted proteinase chymotrypsin (Chtr) is between the P1 and P1Ј residues. The native serpin structure is unusual in that it is metastable and is considered to be in a stressed (S) conformation. The cleaved serpin released from the complex is much more stable than the intact serpin (2, 3) and is considered to be in a relaxed (R) conformation. Noteworthy among many structural differences between the S and R conformations (4) is the A  sheet, which is converted from ...