Certain bacterial strains from the microbiome induce a potent, antigen-specific T cell response. However, the specificity of microbiome-induced T cells has not been explored at the strain level across the gut community. Here, we colonize germ-free mice with a complex defined community (97 or 112 bacterial strains) and profile T cell responses to each strain individually. Unexpectedly, the pattern of T cell responses suggests that many T cells in the gut repertoire recognize multiple bacterial strains from the community. We constructed T cell hybridomas from 92 T cell receptor (TCR) clonotypes; by screening every strain in the community against each hybridoma, we find that nearly all of the bacteria-specific TCRs exhibit a one-to-many TCR-to-strain relationship, including 13 abundant TCR clonotypes that are polyspecific for 18 Firmicutes in the community. By screening three pooled bacterial genomic libraries against 13 pooled hybridomas, we discover that they share a single target: a conserved substrate-binding protein (SBP) from an ABC transport system. Treg and Th17 cells specific for an epitope from this protein are abundant in community-colonized and specific-pathogen-free mice. Our work reveals that T cell recognition of Firmicutes is focused on a widely conserved cell-surface antigen, opening the door to new therapeutic strategies in which colonist-specific immune responses are rationally altered or redirected.