Anything but a story foretold: multiple politics of resistance to the agrarian extractivist project in Guatemala

Abstract

Sugarcane and oil palm agribusinesses are in the vanguard of an emergent project of agrarian capitalism in Guatemala, which is defined here as a financialized and flexible type of agrarian extractivism. Meanwhile, Maya-Q´eqchi´ residents of the northern lowlands believe that the changes in the labor regime, land relations and the agro-ecosystem that the expansion of these agribusinesses has brought threatens their subsistence in multiple and unfamiliar ways. Indeed, growing difficulties in dealing with (vital) grievances is leading many, even those who initially welcomed the corporate sugarcane and oil palm plantations, to transform their unrest into a practice of resistance. Elaborating on what is presented here as a multiple politics perspective, this article discusses the nature and character of such contemporary political dynamics of agrarian change. The forms, strategies, and practices of the two main and most antagonistic repertoires of contention are explored here: the one in "defense of territory" and the one in the promotion of the "agrarian extractivist project". The tensions across and within multiple corporate, state and social actors who are pushing for, resisting, complying with, or operating at the most violent margins of the agrarian extractivist project are also examined. By assessing continuities and ruptures between current and previous cycles of contention around the control of land, water and other natural resources, this article stresses the often-forgotten lesson about trajectories of agrarian change not being a story foretold, but the product of multiple and dynamic politics.

Organizing against Land Grabbing in Cambodia: Exploring Missing Links

“…In relation to land grabbing, a particular phenomenon that we have seen in recent years is the linking of resistance to indigenous identities. Resistance discourses increasingly draw on the cultural and symbolic value that land has in many indigenous communities (Alonso‐Fradejas, ; Buckley, ; Escobar, ). Indeed, land disputes are often underpinned by contests over the meaning of land.…”

Securing the Return: How EnhancedUSBorder Enforcement Fuels Cycles of Debt Migration

“…Restructuring across Latin America has “reduced economic spaces” and prompted a “crisis” in traditional livelihoods for many campesino groups (Hecht :164–165; Kay ). In Guatemala, national reforms, followed by the 2006 Central American Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA), eliminated the market viability of traditional maize production for smallholders without providing clear economic alternatives (Alonso‐Fradejas ; Isakson ). Greater integration with deregulated global markets eroded seasonal labour opportunities in traditional export economies like coffee (Velázquez Nimatuj ).…”

“…Greater integration with deregulated global markets eroded seasonal labour opportunities in traditional export economies like coffee (Velázquez Nimatuj ). Meanwhile, a renewed agrarian extractivist project for primary materials and multi‐use flex crops such as sugarcane and palm oil has fuelled land grabs while offering limited opportunities for rural work (Alonso‐Fradejas ).…”

Land grabbing, land rush, controle e estrangeirização da terra: uma análise dos temas e tendências da produção acadêmica entre 2009 e 2017

“…Mamonova (2015) declara que as primeiras pesquisas passaram a impressão de que as resistências ao controle de terras eram bastante simplificadas, quando na realidade é algo muito mais complexo. As pesquisas da segunda fase dão um enfoque maior nas formas de resistências, como os estudos de Borras Júnior e Franco (2013), Hall et al (2015), Alonso-Fradejas (2015), Moreda (2015;2016) e Pereira (2015b. Estas pesquisas priorizam as diferentes formas de resistências das distintas comunidades locais, o que os autores intitulam de resistências from below.…”