Application of Multi-Actor Multi-Criteria Analysis for Transition Management in Energy Communities

Lode, Maria Luisa; Boveldt, Geert te; Macharis, Cathy; Coosemans, Thierry

doi:10.3390/su13041783

Cited by 10 publications

(6 citation statements)

References 52 publications

(68 reference statements)

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…MCA can be applied through many approaches for the aggregation of results [103,104]. The mostly used method is the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) [99,105,106], which is based on the paired comparison of the criteria to determine the weighting factors of the criteria; while the PROMETHEE method is used in [107] and the Hermione methodology in [96]. The approaches differ in the definition and ranking of the criteria used to analyze the sustainability of the proposed urban scenarios.…”

Section: Literature Review Resultsmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…However, it is highlighted that specific business models tailored for the optimization of PEDs using digital twins are missing. Despite this, within the literature experiences, advanced energy management strategies are taken into consideration only in [106,157] through MCA and in [155], where metrics are used.…”

mentioning

confidence: 99%

“…More in detail, in [106], a scenario based on energy cooperation and the use of a P2P platform in which citizens participate is studied. This case is compared with another scenario based on the creation of a virtual network of digitally connected prosumers in the hypothesis of flexible prices.…”

mentioning

confidence: 99%

“…On the other hand, in [195], the potential of mobile apps aimed at directing citizens' awareness towards eco-sustainable actions is highlighted, also in relation to the possible reduction in the carbon footprint in Positive Energy Districts. The Living Lab concept is further developed in [106]. Specifically, authors have developed an MCA optimized in the involvement, interaction and empowerment of users and in co-participation along the district planning process, the Multi-Actor Multi Criteria Analysis (MCMCA).…”

mentioning

confidence: 99%

See 3 more Smart Citations

Environmental Sustainability Approaches and Positive Energy Districts: A Literature Review

et al. 2021

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

During the last decade, increasing attention has been paid to the emerging concept of Positive Energy Districts (PED) with the aim of pushing the transition to clean energy, but further research efforts are needed to identify design approaches optimized from the point of view of sustainable development. In this context, this literature review is placed, with a specific focus on environmental sustainability within innovative and eco-sustainable districts. The findings show that some sustainability aspects such as sustainable food, urban heat islands mitigation and co-impacts, e.g., green gentrification, are not adequately assessed, while fragmented thinking limits the potential of circularity. In this regard, targeted strategies should be developed. On the other hand, the Key Performance Indicators framework needs some integrations. In this direction, indicators were suggested, among those defined in the Sustainable Development Agenda, the main European standards and initiatives and the relevant literature experiences. Future outlooks should be directed towards: the harmonization of the Life Cycle Assessment in PEDs with reference to modeling assumptions and analysis of multiple impacts; the development of dynamic environmental analyses taking into account the long-term uncertainty due to climate change, data availability and energy decarbonization; the combination of Life Cycle Assessment and Key Performance Indicators based techniques, from a holistic thinking perspective, for a comprehensive design environment and the analysis of the contribution of energy flexibility approaches on the environmental impact of a project.

show abstract

Section: Literature Review Resultsmentioning

confidence: 99%

mentioning

confidence: 99%

mentioning

confidence: 99%

mentioning

confidence: 99%

See 2 more Smart Citations

Environmental Sustainability Approaches and Positive Energy Districts: A Literature Review

et al. 2021

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…However, Rotmans and Loorbach [5] argue that it is still possible to influence and guide, in terms of shaping the emergence and direction of these processes. Still, previous research on transition management provides limited insights into how individuals and organizations can, might, or should act in the present to affect processes of transition or to steer trajectories towards desired goals [1,6].…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

Preparing an Organization for Sustainability Transitions—The Making of Boundary Spanners through Design Training

Yström

Agogué

Rampa³

2021

Sustainability

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Organizations today need to adapt their operations for a more sustainable future, and the transition management literature has highlighted the need for individuals who can collaborate with others to find new paths forward. Essentially, these individuals are boundary spanners with specific skills and competences to bridge diverging perspectives and facilitate knowledge dissemination and integration. Such individuals become critical change agents in organizations and essential in preparing the organization for sustainability transitions. The purpose of this study is to explore how organizations can enable and encourage individuals to take on this role and develop the skills and competences needed to become boundary spanners. Based on a case study set in a large Canadian energy corporation striving to shift towards more sustainable operations, our paper explores the emergence of boundary spanners, focusing on the effects of a design training program in supporting such roles in the organization. Our findings outline essential characteristics of boundary spanners; through illustrative career trajectories of four individuals participating in the training program, we show how the training program contributed to the emergence of boundary spanners.

show abstract

Criteria preprocessing in multi‐actor multi‐criteria analysis

Huang

Canoy

Brusselaers

et al. 2023

Multi Criteria Decision Anal

Self Cite

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Multi‐actor multi‐criteria analysis is a group decision‐making framework that allows multiple stakeholder groups to be involved in the decision‐making process, facilitating the understanding of the points of consensus and conflict among the stakeholder groups. Carefully selecting suitable criteria is important as they illustrate the possibly divergent priorities of the respective stakeholder group, and overlooking important criteria can lead to erroneous outcomes. Furthermore, the number of criteria needs specific consideration, as a too large number poses problems for human cognition, but a too small number inaccurately represents the stakeholder's interest. In stakeholder groups with many members, such as those representing citizens, defining a criteria set is likely to be even more complicated. Currently, there is no formal guideline to assist facilitators in defining these criteria sets. In this paper, we propose a novel framework for criteria preprocessing with stakeholder involvement that includes a guideline for firstly selecting criteria into a tentative list and secondly selecting the final criteria set. It provides a procedure on how to determine criteria considering the priorities of stakeholder groups with regard to the context. As a final step, we propose a mathematical model for selecting a number of criteria that are both cognitively manageable and representative for the participants' priorities. Based on the principles of the Pareto analysis, as well as the cognitive judgment theory “magic number seven plus or minus two”, a recommendation list of the criteria is generated. It prevents key criteria from being omitted while at the same time limiting the overall number of criteria. This framework is applied to a social decision‐making case for construction logistics, and the results are compared with the conventional approach of criteria definition.

show abstract

Application of Multi-Actor Multi-Criteria Analysis for Transition Management in Energy Communities

Cited by 10 publications

References 52 publications

Environmental Sustainability Approaches and Positive Energy Districts: A Literature Review

Environmental Sustainability Approaches and Positive Energy Districts: A Literature Review

Preparing an Organization for Sustainability Transitions—The Making of Boundary Spanners through Design Training

Criteria preprocessing in multi‐actor multi‐criteria analysis

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About