“…The variation in the relative rates for ring closure of 14 (R 1 R 2 N = Me 2 N, PhNH, MeNH, and NH 2 ) of 7.5 × 10 4 :5.2 × 10 3 :140:1 is striking. The electron donor effect of the groups in stabilizing the incipient cyclobutenediones as measured by the respective σ p + constants of −1.70, −1.40, −1.81, and −1.30, respectively, would contribute to this difference, although the data for R = MeNH do not fit the trend. However, the σ p + constant for this substituent 11c was obtained in a separate study by a different laboratory than the others, and this may cause the inconsistency.…”