Military veterans are exposed to a number of traumatic stressors during their military service. These stressors may be related to combat (e.g., rifle and mortar fire, improvised explosive devices) and situations other than combat (e.g., sexual assault, training accidents). Both forms of traumatic stressors are associated with negative mental health consequences, in part due to the meaning veterans make of them (i.e., posttraumatic cognitions). Posttraumatic cognitions that develop in the aftermath of trauma often involve negative thoughts of the self, the world, and self-blame. However, trauma is not the only factor associated with posttraumatic cognitions. Another factor that may influence posttraumatic cognitions is personality, which is often conceptualized in terms of five traits (agreeableness, conscientiousness, extraversion, neuroticism, and openness). Research suggests that of these traits, neuroticism has the strongest association with posttraumatic cognitions over and above trauma, although this has not been examined with respect to military trauma. In this study, we examined the influence of military trauma (i.e., combat and noncombat trauma), and personality traits on posttraumatic cognitions in a sample of veterans (N = 93) recruited through Amazon's Mechanical Turk. Results suggest that neuroticism had a strong association with each posttraumatic cognition and that combat and negative life events had small associations with negative thoughts of the self and the world, respectively. These findings highlight the role of personality in posttraumatic cognitions and underscore the importance of considering neuroticism in clinical treatment.