Appraisal of the methodological quality of clinical practice guidelines in the Philippines

Abstract

Summary Purpose The Republic of the Philippines has recently enacted the Universal Health Care Law, which mandates the Philippines Department of Health (DOH) to operationalize evidence‐based clinical practice guideline (CPG) development. As a baseline to the foregoing task, the aim of this study was to appraise the methodological quality of CPGs previously developed and currently being disseminated in the Philippines. A multimethod search for CPGs was implemented. CPGs were independently evaluated using a modified version of the Knowledge Management Plus CPG appraisal tool. Findings Eighty‐seven CPGs were included in the appraisal. Majority implemented processes to ensure validity, ie, consideration for patient groups, management options, benefits, and harms (99%), and indicated strength of their recommendations (89%). Seventy‐seven CPGs (89%) evaluated the evidence for local applicability. Of the 87 CPGs, 20 CPGs (23%) considered equity in the development process. The development process differed among CPGs with varying degrees of utilization of GRADE methodology (52%), disclosure of funding sources (72%), and engagement of technical support external to the development body (3%). Mean duration of CPG development was 1 year (SD 5.9 months), and mean interval between updates was 6 years and 1 month (SD 37.8 months). Conclusion Although most of the CPGs fulfilled essential criteria for quality recommendations (validity and applicability), equity considerations were limited. Furthermore, only half used the GRADE approach and development and dissemination practices differed substantially between CPGs. Thus, it is recommended that a standard CPG development process be made available by the DOH to be utilized by CPG developers in the Philippines.

Data-Driven Treatment Pathways Mining for Early Breast Cancer Using cSPADE Algorithm and System Clustering

“…3 West China Biomedical Big Data Center, West China Hospital, Sichuan University, Chengdu, China. 4 Laboratory of Molecular Diagnosis of Cancer, Clinical Research Center for Breast, West China Hospital, Sichuan University, Chengdu, China.…”

Effect of a Brief Training Program on the Knowledge of Filipino Primary Care Providers in a Rural and a Remote Setting: a Before and After Study

“…The implementation of UHC and provision of primary care services, however, have been negatively affected by the COVID-19 pandemic with increasing disparities in access to quality care particularly in low-and middle-income countries. 5 Up-to-date clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) are central topics in traditional and blended educational interventions, 6 and are critical in ensuring quality care is provided to patients. CPGs give evidence-based directives to aid in the delivery of standardized treatment plans.…”

Data‐driven treatment pathways mining for early breast cancer using cSPADE algorithm and system clustering

“…There are obvious gaps in the level of diagnosis and treatment equipment and technology in different regions and different hospitals. Inadequate compliance and lack of standardisation in guidelines, specifications and paths have hindered the improvement of the overall level of care 4 . However, Chinese women are different from women in Europe and the United States in many aspects, such as breast structure, sex hormone levels, eating habits, and living environment.…”

“…Inadequate compliance and lack of standardisation in guidelines, specifications and paths have hindered the improvement of the overall level of care. 4 However, Chinese women are different from women in Europe and the United States in many aspects, such as breast structure, sex hormone and lift were greater than 0.89. Using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test, we found no significant differences between the sequence distributions.…”